when he is aged/when he aged?

2020-11-03 6:01 am
Which one is correct?

1. I like him when he is aged.
2. I like him when he aged.

回答 (3)

2020-11-07 9:19 pm
✔ 最佳答案
橘子小姐好久不見了.你還在做廣告事業嗎?

aged這字可以做動詞用,也可以做形容詞用.但是意思有些不同.

1. I like him when he is aged.

aged在這裡是形容詞(不是被動動詞)是當作"(心理,做人,行為上)成熟的,老成的"的意思.

所以這句話是:我愛成熟的,老成的犯人.

2. I like him when he aged.

aged在這裡是動詞(不是形容詞)是當作"成長"的意思. 

所以這句話是: 我愛成長大以後的犯人.

3.考試:以下2句話的英語怎麼寫?

他變得越來越老了。
他變得越來越老成了.

太好了。橘子小姐好犀利。應該很快就會得到諾貝爾文學獎。我一定參加妳的頒獎典禮。
2020-11-03 3:19 pm
(2)aged=adj=very old; 
an aged old man---correct.
(1)when he is aged 80=ageing to become 80 yso------no complement
2020-11-04 11:43 am
I like him when he aged. = 當他老了之後我"仍"喜歡他。
I like him when he is aged = 當他已經是一個老人時我"才"會喜歡他。

兩句都沒錯的,按文法/語法/習慣法只是意義上有點分別。(雖然兩句的對象都是老時,但"我"所表達對他的意義是不同的)

你這例句還有一樣相約的東西可代替"他"(人),試代入"酒"亦有相似的含意分別:

I like this wine when it aged. = 這酒存了長時間便使我喜歡。
I like this wine when it is aged = 這酒是存了足夠長的時間後才會是我喜歡的。


若然必定要選擇一句(對錯選),我會說I like him when he aged.
因為若說I like him when he is aged. = I don't like him now.  I only like him until he is old (old enough in my standard).  這含意有點"否定"他在我的看法中的現存價值,很有侮辱性。


收錄日期: 2021-04-11 23:22:30
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20201102220113AAqeNVh

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份