Are you criticism objective?

Garlic2010, I totally agree with your point at this time. Although Radioman rewrote the answer correctly, Radioman had failed to clarify the whole point that the thread holder was asking.

2011-06-07 20:55:33 補充：
I was asking you whether your criticism are objective, and you answered me "without a doubt they are". Who are THEY?

When you invite your instructor to sit beside you, you can say you have your instructor sit beside you.

Giving command is just one use of have\\+ bare infinitive.

2011-06-07 14:25:27 補充：
It is a fact that Radioman did not address the question of the poster, that is, whether "sit" was to be changed to present tense.

It was obvious that the poster had assumed that "sit" was a verb in the sentence.

2011-06-07 14:27:06 補充：
\\If one fails to see this, he is not giving a useful answer to the poster. \\You can write a correct English sentence but that does not equate to an answer.

2011-06-07 14:37:27 補充：
What about changing Radioman's sentence to:
"Did an instructor sit beside you giving you directions?"
"Did an instructor sit beside and give you directions?"
Should "giving" be changed to present tense?
That was the kind of question the poster had.

2011-06-07 14:43:00 補充：
On his answer to this thread
http://hk.knowledge.yahoo.com/question/question?qid=7011042501466,
Radioman only answered #3 of the four questions by the poster.
Again, that was not addressing the queries of the poster.

2011-06-07 14:50:53 補充：
If we are not sure what the poster is asking (not thinking), we can ask him to clarify his question, or supply our answers based on our best guess.
To answer your question on whether my criticisms are objective, without a doubt they are.

2011-06-08 00:49:23 補充：
Your question is "Are your criticism(s) objective". "They" refer to the criticisms in your question.