Who’s playing whom?

2007-05-22 8:56 am
是哪兩隊對打?
playing 後加 whom 不明?whom 是什麼詞?playing whom,gerund phrase?怎解?
Who’s playing,明!誰在打緊。

回答 (3)

2007-05-22 9:18 pm
✔ 最佳答案
其實你這句有兩個意思,因為在這裏的play可作”同某人比賽解”,又可作”扮演”解。
至於Who是作為疑問代名詞,是指”誰”、”甚麼人”
而whom也是用作疑問代名詞,作”甚麼人”、”誰”,不過是用作object,如,yahoo字典也有一例:
1. (用作疑問代名詞)誰,什麼人
I know who you are and whom you represent.
我知道你是誰並代表誰。
而playing whom並不是gerund phrase,而這句是這樣看:who (is playing) whom
who(疑問代名詞:主詞)+is playing(現在進行式)+whom(受詞)?
若這樣拆開後,整句的意思就非常明顯,是:
誰正跟誰比賽?(所以,也可譯作哪兩隊對賽)
或者 誰正扮演誰?(是指甚麼人正飾演甚麼角色),而且若你在網上搜尋,你會找到who should play whom或who would play whom等等,都是指著飾演來說。
真正的意思是甚麼意思,就要看前文後理了。
2007-05-22 6:35 pm
照字面解以上位朋友解釋得好好,但呢句其實係有一個口語化意思,就係一個人唔滿意另外一個人玩弄佢時,就會勞勞氣氣咁話:依家究意係邊個玩緊邊個?
參考: 自己
2007-05-22 1:15 pm
whom 同who 係幾乎一樣,不過whom係用於object 而who係subject.
e.g. Sarah is giving a present to Emma 改為問題會變成
Who is giving a present to Emma? 答: Sarah
To whom is Sarah giving a present? 答: Emma

或者同黎連接
I'm going to meet Amy who goes to my school. 因為 I'm going to meet Amy. Amy goes to my school.
I'm going to meet Amy whom I don't like. 因為 I'm going to meet Amy. I don't like Amy.

Hope that has helped.


收錄日期: 2021-04-18 22:17:56
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20070522000051KK00243

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份