先行詞為people及those的句子：People that are nice will help others.不可用that,為何,該用who嗎?
回答 (2)
2020-08-31 3:38 pm
People that are=Those who are
That can be used instead of who or which
=eg:-The people and those e-machines that produce the TW nation's wealth.
That cannot be used instead of who or which
eg:-People that are nice **that**will help others---no need "that"
eg:-Those who are nice **that** will help others---no need *that*
That can be used instead of who or which
=eg:-The people and those e-machines that produce the TW nation's wealth.
That cannot be used instead of who or which
eg:-People that are nice **that**will help others---no need "that"
eg:-Those who are nice **that** will help others---no need *that*
2020-08-31 1:53 pm
People that are nice will help others. (that在此為限定用法的關係代名詞，前面的先行詞可以是人或物）
= Those who are nice will help others.(who在此也是限定用法的關係代名詞，前面通常為人或擬人化的事物）
先行詞Those（指示代名詞）指的是「人」時，用who...的形容詞子句來加以限定是合理的。但如果those所指的是「物」，通常會用形容詞子句that/which ...來限定。
= Those who are nice will help others.(who在此也是限定用法的關係代名詞，前面通常為人或擬人化的事物）
先行詞Those（指示代名詞）指的是「人」時，用who...的形容詞子句來加以限定是合理的。但如果those所指的是「物」，通常會用形容詞子句that/which ...來限定。
收錄日期: 2021-05-01 00:37:30
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20200831050841AANkNXO