一個英語"疑問句"的問題:?

2020-07-26 1:03 am
One of the big trees had been partly chopped through, and standing beside it, with an uplifted axe in his hands, was a man made entirely of tin.

請問這句話裡面的"was a man made entirely of tin"是問句嗎?

書上寫"was it a man made entirely of tin?"才是問句.為什麼要加it?

a man was made entirely of tin把a man和was換位不就是問句嗎?

回答 (4)

2020-07-26 3:39 am
✔ 最佳答案
我猜這是綠野仙踪的一句. 

這裏沒有問句. 整句的結構是 句1 and 句2
句1是One of the big trees had been partly chopped through
句2是standing beside it was a man made entirely of tin. 那with an uplifted axe in his hands是形容那個tin man. 句2是倒裝句, 原句是a man made entirely of tin was standing beside it. 這裏的it是指那棵被砍的樹. 
2020-07-26 6:41 pm
The word seem are used in this pattern. If the infinitive is be with an adjective or noun  as complement, to be may be omitted(unless the adjective is one that is used only predicatively, 
eg:-He seemed----subject +seem
to be made of tin-------(to be)+adjective/noun;a statement, not a question eg:-Was a man made entirely of tin?-------(x)
---------------
One of the big trees had been partly chopped through,------sentence one
and standing beside it-----it=obj;adj cl,not question;----co-sentence
(with an uplifted axe in his hands,)-----inserted adj phr to a man--invertion
was a man-----v+s===>s+v not a question as sentence two
made entirely of tin----adj cl to "a man"
Re:-A man was made entirely of tin..Re:-=He seemed to be made of tin----a statement,--------------(o)
-----A man was made entirely of tin...Re:-=He seemed to be made of tin-----a question-------------(x)From the wonderful world of Oz; a story from former the "prisoner",etc.
2020-07-28 3:21 pm
Was it a man made entirely of tin ? 才是 正確文法

Was he a man 怎樣怎樣 ,是 疑問句,問 一個男人 是不是 怎樣怎樣 

而 錫製的人 不是 人類 ,疑問句 就變 was it 
2020-07-26 9:04 am
standing beside it(that省略) was a man made entirely of tin. 原來it 出現在此,且是以關係子句出現而非疑問句,至於,with an uplifted axe in his hands,是插入句修飾it,本句重點是要先知道全句所要表達意思,若断章取義則無法分析全句


收錄日期: 2021-05-01 00:37:59
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20200725170303AAxhI41

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份