Does God’s foreknowledge of the future contradict our free will?
回答 (15)
2020-07-09 1:22 pm
The weatherman said Monday that it would rain here today, and it rained cats and dogs. But did he MAKE it rain?
Of course not.
Of course not.
2020-07-10 10:27 am
Of course not. God, from His position outside of time and pace, views the fullness of time and space eternally and simultaneously. At this moment He is viewing the creation of the universe, its eventual destruction, and every event that occurs between the two. At this moment He is seeing me doing what I did 5 years ago, and what I will be doing 5 years from now. Obviously, someone simply watching me make decisions, either from a viewpoint here in time, or from God's viewpoint outside of time, has no influence on the freedom of those decisions.
2020-07-09 3:14 pm
No, He knows all our options, and the results, but our free will gives us the choices.
2020-07-09 2:54 pm
God does not have to foreknow everything that happens to us. The idea that God chooses beforehand which trials we will face implies that he must know everything about our future. But such a view is not Scriptural. God certainly can foreknow the future. (Isa. 46:10) But the Bible shows that he is selective when it comes to foreknowing future events. (Gen. 18:20, 21; 22:12) He thus balances his power of foreknowledge with his respect for our free will. Is that not what we would expect from the God who values our freedom and who always exercises his attributes in perfect balance?—Deut. 32:4; 2 Cor. 3:17.
2020-07-10 11:50 am
No, it contradicts the idea of God and free agency, completely. God is not a "psychic" or "fortune-teller". That is humans anthropomorphically projecting "personhood" onto Divinity. An 'Omniscient God' can know every possible outcome to every possible choice, but does not know "how we will choose" (instant to instant); because finite time, as in "past, present and future", doesn't apply to an 'Eternal Being'.
2020-07-10 4:24 am
Not necessarily.
All will be tempted, but the strong and the fearful will be able to resist.
Still, someone will violate the rules.
All will be tempted, but the strong and the fearful will be able to resist.
Still, someone will violate the rules.
2020-07-09 10:48 pm
Does God know in advance everything that people will do? God’s ability to foreknow and foreordain is clearly stated in the Bible. Jehovah himself sets forth as proof of his Godship this ability to foreknow and foreordain events of salvation and deliverance, as well as acts of judgment and punishment, and then to bring such events to fulfillment. (Isa. 44:6-9; 48:3-8) Such divine foreknowledge and foreordination form the basis for all true prophecy.
God challenges the gods of the nations opposing his people to furnish proof of the godship that is claimed for their idol-gods, he calling on these gods to do so by foretelling similar acts of salvation or judgment and then bringing them to pass. Their impotency in this respect demonstrates their idols to be ‘mere wind and unreality.’—Isa. 41:1-10, 21-29; 43:9-15; 45:20, 21.
God challenges the gods of the nations opposing his people to furnish proof of the godship that is claimed for their idol-gods, he calling on these gods to do so by foretelling similar acts of salvation or judgment and then bringing them to pass. Their impotency in this respect demonstrates their idols to be ‘mere wind and unreality.’—Isa. 41:1-10, 21-29; 43:9-15; 45:20, 21.
參考: jw.org
2020-07-09 1:50 pm
no
you only have free will in making the choice
God and life after death or no GOD and delete on death . The rest he has no interest in
you only have free will in making the choice
God and life after death or no GOD and delete on death . The rest he has no interest in
2020-07-09 1:24 pm
If your mother knows that you are going to be bad, say on a hunch, and waits to punish you after you have done so, did she interfere with your free will? No. You still exercise your right to be bad and disobey her prior admonitions. And you totally own your bad behavior. The only way your mother could have stopped you from misbehaving would be to take your "free will" away and constrain you, perhaps lock you up in your bedroom. In a similar manner, God also knows, with total certainty, what it is that you are going to do, and lets you do it. You are still responsible for your behavior. You may have the thought that God knows what you are going to do, and you still do it. I would say that that is certainly "free will".
2020-07-09 1:23 pm
No...because superstition has no rules so predetermination and randomness mean the same thing..
收錄日期: 2021-05-04 03:00:38
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20200709051738AAVwUox