Is the novel 'Moby Dick' really about white superiority as portrayed by the recent Moby Dick musical?

2019-12-16 12:55 am

回答 (15)

2019-12-18 4:38 am
✔ 最佳答案
People say that Moby Dick is about a gay male of leisure activities(Ishmael) who memorizes all there is to know about whaling so that he can hang out with fishermen who he is sexually attracted to. The life lesson of Moby Dick is to not let your genitalia lead you in life. Most literature professors are gay and so they will hype up books that have gay characters in them and Moby Dick is one of those books.
2019-12-16 6:40 am
No, that's stupid.  "Race" isn't the issue.  The story is all about one man's obsession.
2019-12-16 5:56 am
No.


_________
2019-12-16 3:39 am
no, it's about obsession.
2019-12-16 2:29 am
How would a recent Moby Dick musical be allowed to promote white superiority? It would be an economic kiss of death for all concerned.

Ahab was a New England (American Yankee) whaleboat captain. One harpooner in his crew was definitely not a white man. A skilled harpooner was an essential member of the crew so he was probably treated with the respect due to his job. Moby Dick was a very angry white whale (possibly a sperm whale)

You should study the books about the book, but I think it was a man versus nature and the sea story.
2019-12-17 7:26 am
No. It’s about ‘hubris’ and blasphemy. These authors were very intelligent people (Melville was a genius, As were a number of other authors and poets of his era) and they based a lot of their works on Greek classics, Greek and Roman Mythology, the Bible, Shakespeare , etc. And the concept of “hubris” (Pride against nature, pride against God and so on) plays a big part in the classic Greek tragedies.I’ve read a lot of Dick and I didn’t pick up on any racial overtones. In fact in my opinion Moby Dick the Whale  actually represented God. Captain Ahab was ‘going against God’ with his obsession in killing this whale. White symbolizes spirituality and purity among other things. As a matter of fact,  there is a whole chapter in that novel devoted to the symbolism of the color ‘white’ and it doesn’t go into racial issues that I can remember. (Although I would have to look at it again to make sure.) Even Captain Ahab’s  crewmembers felt Obsessively hunting down and killing this whale was an act of blasphemy on a Ahab’s  part.. On the other hand this bad@$$ whale  did take off Ahab’s leg so who can blame him? And any of the biographies of Herman Melville or synopses of that novel I’ve seen have never mentioned racial themes per se. There’s a lot of creative freedom which goes along with creating musicals. They don’t necessarily have to be true to the original literary sources. Poetic license. 
2019-12-18 7:22 am
I don't really think so. I didn't get that impression when reading it.
2019-12-17 12:09 am
I personally didn't pick up anything like that, I saw it more as being about toxic masculinity and the negative effects striving obsessively to be a "real man" has on men.
參考: the book itself and the skills i learned in english lit
2019-12-18 12:41 am
No, that is just a lazy interpretation so you can get invited to campus cocktail parties with all the Deans. Toe the line sister and don't rock the boat.
2019-12-16 12:58 am
Idk about that but what I do know is that the whale Moby DICK is also a SPERM whale. Seems kinda gay...which shouldn't be a problem if you like that sort of thing I guess don't get mad plz
2019-12-16 11:55 pm
Yes, I picked up those themes 
2019-12-18 7:08 am
no. it is about man's search for the spiritual.
some people just want to make everything about themselves as their own race. this is what is called "art", it does not have to be realistic or about truth, so taking the basic theme of "moby dick", someone makes it say that "racism is their thing". 
i question their work, though, as whether is it is about modern equality and peace for all.
2019-12-16 1:30 am
Seems like one of revenge but Ishmail didn't consider what the Bible says about vengeance at Romans 12:19 - “‘Vengeance is mine; I will repay,’ says Jehovah.”
Maybe God got revenge on Ishmail for hunting one of his creatures. Idk. 
2019-12-17 11:50 am
Ridiculous ??:,? csgtyhvx du b c
2019-12-17 6:38 am
no its not about whites being better then other races or race at all its about caption Abhab wanting revenge on a wheal named mobi dick and his obsession of the wheal just read the novel who ever wrote the play a idiot 
參考: i read the book


收錄日期: 2021-04-24 07:43:53
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20191215165548AAYZgXj

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份