英文的問題,求解!?

2019-04-13 10:21 am
1.It was the most exciting trip that I [ ].
(A)have ever had
(B)had ever had
為甚麼答案是A?

回答 (7)

2019-04-13 10:58 am
✔ 最佳答案
had had是「過去完成式」,用在過去發生的兩動作中先發生的那一件,後發生的那一件用「簡單過去式」。
但本句並無兩件過去的事。而ever(曾經)的時間點是截至目前為止,所以用「現在完成式」動詞have ever had。
It was ....用「簡單式過去式」,因為所述是「過去」為真的事實。
如果寫作it is....,be動詞用「簡單現在式」則表示「永遠」為真。不符邏輯,因為以後我無法確知以後不會有更棒的旅行。
2019-04-15 10:24 am
It was the most exciting trip that I have ever had.
它是我曾經擁有的最刺激的旅行。

簡單的說
"我曾經擁有最..........."
這樣的語意,都是指"到目前為止"比較出的經驗,即是"在目前為止,最刺激的"當然必須以現在完成式來表達。
而"那次旅行"是過去發生的,故使用過去式was.
2019-04-13 6:20 pm
It was the most exciting trip ---S+V
(A) correct;that I have ever had----------that as noun clause as complement
Experience:-eg:-I went to a trip
and
have had=have ever had
=have ever had an exciting trip
=have ever had the most exciting trip.
=(with feeling and thought.)
(B) Incorrect:-had had----the past perfect tense=the pluperfect=(grammar) the form of a verb expresses an action completed before a particular point in the past(=had+past participle-----past tense?!)
=eg:-It was the most exciting trip that I had ever had before I died------No past perfect tense mentioned.
eg:-I had had the exciting trip last week before I died today suddenly-------No past perfect tense mentioned also.
2019-04-13 10:39 am
was代表過去發生的trip
但到現在還是很刺激,所以是用現在完成式
原句可看成It was the most exciting trip that I have ever had
that子句是補充說明那場旅行
2019-04-13 6:05 pm
這個問題牽涉到發生時間奌且句中用了二個時式:過去式及現在完成式,本句顯然是指過去並持續進行至現在,所以首段是將過去時間指出用was,而持續至現在用have had。
至於為何不能用过去完成式,因為用此時式必須發生事件比过去事件之前,例如I had never seen such a beautiful beach before I went to this place. 在我未到此處之前,從未看到如此美的海灘,所以用法有所區別
本句若改疹It had been the most exciting trip before I had. (Ok)
2019-04-14 7:16 am
簡單來說就是had要有兩個動作
一個動作用have就好
2019-04-13 12:18 pm
我小五,我的英文練習有以下這道題:
Have you ever been to Macao?
Yes,I've been there.
以上題目的have在ever前
(之後我不懂解釋了)


收錄日期: 2021-04-18 18:16:31
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20190413022139AAEJvQE

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份