In my opinion, I think evening shift because everyone is coming home from their jobs and picking up dinner for the kids. But that also depends if it is a safe area, some places are shifty at night around 2 because people were out drinking.
The pay might be better. What matters is, can you adjust your sleep hours AND be able to sleep during the day without everyone and their meemaw waking you up.
Depends on if you're a night owl or not. If you normally don't go to sleep until 2 or 3 in the morning, then it's a good shift. If you're a morning person, it will be difficult.