Could somebody critique this poem?

2018-02-11 10:46 am
Between the cloudland After-death
Where archetypes choke the fancy's breath -
And Underneath, the slave-world's girth
Where confrontation binds men's mirth -
Between, recline the downs Compose
Where thrives imagination's nose.

Above, sky's science-loving sea
Where freezes fabulosity;
Below is Vision's workhouse grim
Where businessmen indenture him!
Amidmost, groves of Artistry
Where feeling throbs, alive and free.

Reluctance here's beset with lots
Of gentle heart-seducing plots,
And here in children's sun of Morn
Congeal the gifts wherewith they're born;
From this alone of worlds that are
May poets hope to reach some star.

回答 (10)

2018-02-12 3:14 am
✔ 最佳答案
Metrically, it soars, but I disagree with 5/7 that the rhymes are unforced. Here and there, I know you're reaching, trying to keep the point of your crayon inside the lines of form. I can't FAULT that, 'cause I do it myself. That aside, formally it's great work.

Thematically, you bite off a big chunk. Not every reader will have the teeth to chew it. Do you think you reached that segment of the readership you aimed for? If so, kudos!

But, um, here I deviate from criticism: I live to reach that kid who was a numbskull, until my words eased the paralysis of thought; you can't do that with lines that are too oblique, nor with allusions that are too obscure for the unscholarly.
2018-02-11 11:52 am
I commend you for your unique rhymes which also flow.
This is good,science-loving sea,fabulosity
2018-02-11 10:57 am
This is creative. I like the mens mirth line.. that was funny lol. Is it all truly what you wrote down from your conscience and heart? Its being distinct in its own individual right. It actually does connect to how my perspective is which is why i aknowledge it. Im not experienced that much so i can only use imagery with some the passages in here im familiar with. I give it 3 thumbs up id give you an extra 2 if i grew another set
2018-02-12 2:36 am
Live from Malta

very good stuff
it made my heart race
as i read
i like how you stuck it in:)
almost his life lost at sea
when from the fire

a venomous viper latched on to and
hung from his hand
as the barbarians watched supposing he would fall down dead
yet he just shook it off

but seriouly i think there are to many "where"s??? malita
and maybe just maybe change archetypes choke to
art -achokes type :)
cause this is mykind a poem
參考: greek myth: Jupiter
2018-02-11 9:27 pm
What this site is about. I hope this is yours. It's deep yet understandable, couplet rhyme seems unforced, the message isn't strictly happy, but realistic. A minimum of EWD, extra word disorder. Well done.
2018-02-11 6:11 pm
OMG! Did you write this or was it penned in distant days past?

It's too perfect to critique!
From the mind of a unique freak!
Oh, I do adore, "imagination's nose"

"gentle heart-seducing plots", is just too good, way too good!

This poem is obviously written by a very experienced professional poet or it is a classic, already previously published by an author we all know!

I don't know who, but "WOW"

It magically inspired my mind.
A key unlocked a soul-door!

I want to read it everyday so that my mind might recite it prayer-like.

Oh My God!!!
2018-02-13 5:17 am
I like it. I am not sure what it all means but that to me is the nature of poetry that there are multiple ways to interpret some of it.
2018-02-12 7:51 am
I loved seeing this poem, a very compelling script... starred this one about five minutes ago, just so I could come back to it.... keep writing! to be cont'd...

I'd like to see the gift flow... not congeal... as this suggest a hardening of the hearts, talents, inspirations constricted. The Rivers of Life must flow if life is to be found, here!

There's much to ask concerning this poem; such as what embodiments do the archetypes host! I'd need to read more of your work, to ascertain the themes... to see what is beyond the veil, perhaps a cradled song!
2018-02-12 7:47 am
As straight blindfold of endeavored
As business as usable to fort somewhat bland and blind
To a nowhereman of ink two step art full --of dead beat (bones)
As Ya for a team- (religion) now of a fort wave cluster f_c_ a flag, that fallen eve, grounded
To paste that never; was, use of women of harlots
Out to lunch and gone fishing but yet not for Him
As so glad to bypass and yet solder coals that fried long ago
As sunshine He here put you to test to wonder to fire to come
But this day and days as past same o now for weeks end the change
The changes of me His own was the day’s time but you have want birth
For in the life of that is the speaking and not of me of You.
But nevertheless, you of some will rise!
Between the cloudland After-death, there if alive will know, disown.
So what do they we have; only truth of heaven and earth will survive?

5 And He took him outside and said, “Now look toward the heavens, and count the stars, if you are able to count them.” And He said to him, “So shall your descendants be.” 6 Then he believed in the LORD; and He reckoned it to him as righteousness. Genesis 15
2018-02-16 1:32 am
ah I rub between my leg as I read it


收錄日期: 2021-04-24 00:59:32
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20180211024658AAgUiMc

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份