Defining and non-defining nouns phrases同Defining and non-defining relative clauses係係咪一樣野?分別點解同點用?

2017-10-10 6:57 pm

回答 (2)

2017-10-10 10:58 pm
✔ 最佳答案
defining and non-defining noun phrases應該稱為defining and non-defining appositives(限定與非限定性質的同位語),如:
James Bacon, a talented man with gray hair, paints in the morning.(非限定的同位語)
Her sister Sandra is coming in June.(限定的同位語,因他的姊妹不止一個,需要限定)
The belief that help would arrive keep them from giving up.(限定的同位語:名詞子句)
同位語都是名詞性質。

defining and non-defining relative clauses則應稱為defining and non-defining modifiers(限定與非限定的修飾語)
「修飾語」是子句時,分為「形容詞子句」與「副詞子句」兩種,修飾的對象不同。
「形容詞子句」當「修飾語」,分為「限定」與「非限定」兩種:
All students who do not study will fail this course.(名詞students的範圍受到了形容詞子句的限定)
He has a friend who is a singer.(名詞friend受到限定)

My grandfather, who is eighty years old, collects stamps.(my grandfather不受形容詞子句的限定,因為是唯一的)
She was with her husband, whom I had already met.(her husband不受限定,因為是唯一的)

「非限定的同位語」和「非限定的修飾語」都要使用「逗號」將它們與其同位和受其修飾的名詞隔開。
2017-10-11 7:09 pm
Sandra would be the one sisters that comes----defining cl.
Sandra would be the one sisters, who comes-----restrictive or non-defining cl.="who"


收錄日期: 2021-04-30 22:17:27
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20171010105701AAU7Mmo

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份