Problem (Present Perfect)?

2016-08-15 12:18 am
Tom 在下午四點問我"Have you had dinner?" ,咁我答她"Very early, I have not had dinner." ,想問問Tom 用現在完成式有無問題。另外我咁樣答她有無問題。

回答 (2)

2016-08-15 2:30 am
Tom用present perfect tense問是可以的,因為他的問題是假設"你現在這時已經吃了晚飯,而想確定/問清楚。"

你回答的主句"I have not had dinner"亦正確回答他的"假設"時空情況。
只不過句前的修飾詞或形容詞"Very early"則不是合格的英文,正確的回答應該是"It is very early,"或"It is too early,"

另外Tom是男性,何解你寫句「我答的是"她"」?
2016-08-15 12:42 am
in my opinion,Tom's QUESTIONS is correct,but your answer"very early" could be better.
依筆者拙見,湯姆的問題是正確的,但您的回答「太早very early」可以改進。
因為您用的結構是"因為太…A…而不能V"
why not say
"it's too early to have dinner "
(現在去吃晚飯還太早)
Or "No,I have not had dinner yet.it's too early."
(不,我還沒吃,現在還太早)


收錄日期: 2021-04-11 21:28:36
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20160814161850AAWQhSY

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份