詐騙罪一案 3月21日，我在羅氏會計事務所申請了債務重組方案，並簽了約，卻未宣誓，但我在4月8日通知他已向另一間會計師行申請了破產，他卻要我賠償他的債務重組方案所有費用$36000，否則他控告我構成詐騙罪，想問一問朋友，我其實有沒有意圖詐騙他?有沒有犯詐騙罪?請大家回覆?

:
大大只有民事的違約 + 民事的賠償；
大大沒有刑事的詐騙啦；

律師，擅長項目之一，就是嚇唬委託人，委託人一緊張，那才有錢賺。

1. Yes.

2. Yes.

Generally speaking, there are 2 kinds of fraud - criminal fraud and civil fraud. Criminal fraud is prosecuted by the Government and civil fraud is prosecuted by the victim.

This case is an example of civil fraud.

Why the firm has a case in this case? The reason is simple - although not required, IVA is usually a step before bankruptcy. When you requested IVA service, you represented yourself as you choose IVA and allowed the firm to work for you. However, you chose bankruptcy instead.

Since you have misrepresented your intention to the firm, the firm can legally go after you for the cost of service.

但我問過律師，他說沒有犯詐騙罪