Ask Present Perfect Tense Problem?

2015-12-02 11:41 pm
英文唔米咁好,就快考DSE,有問題想問問。

Tom 係2010年3月5日去世,我係佢去世之前聯絡過去。想問問大家宜家用"I have contacted Tom." 黎形容我曾經聯絡過Tom。

回答 (3)

2015-12-03 12:29 am
For Wing's DSE:-
contact is state of touching or communication and the process of coming together esp. in "come into contact":-eg:-
Our Wing is in contact with the dead man.
The dying man is now out of contact with each other.
----come into contact with Tom esp. after searching,eg:-
I finally made contact with Tom on March 5,2010 (=5 yrs 8 months ago.).

Present perfect denotes present results of past actions."ever,never for, since, just, already" are used.Only" already" used and applied.eg:-
I have contacted Tom.
I have already contacted Tom.----indicates completion---present perfect.
Wing never succeeded in making "contact" with Tom on March 5,2010(6yrs ago) whether He died or Not !You cannot describe you've already contacted Tom this way.
2015-12-03 5:50 am
首先您要弄明白「現在完成式」的用法

「現在完成式」:1⃣️ 既涉及過去,又聯繫現在。2⃣️ 表示過去已經開始,一直延續到現在的動作或狀態。3⃣️ 表示該動作剛剛完成了。

He has been at this school since eight years ago.

☆★☆★☆★☆★☆★☆★☆★☆

Tom 係2010年3月5日去世,我係佢去世之前聯絡過去。想問問大家宜家用"I have contacted Tom." 黎形容我曾經聯絡過Tom。

"I have contacted Tom." ( X )

☆ I *had ever contacted Tom before he died on March 5, 2010.

註: 用“過去完成式”, 表示2⃣️個過去動作發生的先後。
“ 是死前曾經聯絡過Tom的”。
2015-12-03 4:16 am
無論他死了還是未死都是
I contacted Tom....
不是I have contacted Tom.

至於何時或表達他已死a是在句子中再附加表達而不是tense的作用,動詞的發生時間/情況決定所用時態形式。

I contacted Tom before he died on 5 March 2010.


收錄日期: 2021-04-12 00:09:41
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20151202154114AAz6OoG

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份