後悔簽了文件同意無條件轉讓物業

2015-05-08 5:45 am
求助,是這樣的,

在2008, 我的祖母將她的物業以在律師樓以禮物形式送給我和伯父,但我的業權以信托形式給伯父管理,因此我不能作任何買賣決定。

可是於上個月我的伯父和祖母同時去世,因我和家人失去聯絡,,我到出殯的前兩天才知道事件發生.在出殯當天,所有儀或完結及吃過飯後,我的佰娘叫我留下,有事商討,

在車上,有我,伯娘,她的女兒及表叔在一起,她問我是不是不要業權,(因我曾於2008年向她提及不想接受這份禮物) 由於我仍在難過傷心中,不在狀態,在不加思考下,我對她說不要了,同一時間,她拿出一份預備好的文件,大概意思是我同意將我的業權無條件轉讓給她的女兒. 我在文件上簽署並有她女兒及伯娘和表叔的見證簽署.

她說之後到律師樓補簽文件後便消毀這份文件,

現在我後悔,因在不適當的時間,當時的狀況不佳,亦在毫無心理準備及無有足夠時間考慮下簽了這份文件,

律師樓文件未簽署,我不打算這樣轉讓給她,我可以反口嗎?

回答 (2)

2015-05-08 5:19 pm
✔ 最佳答案
Sorry about your loss.

The answer is yes with several reasons.

1. Trust and Legal Capacity

It is uncertain regarding the nature of the trust (as it depends on the trust document). However, it seems like you are a minor when you are gifted for the property. Hence, the trust.

Trust is a legal entity by itself. Your uncle's death does not dissolve the trust. Unless the condition specified in the trust has been met, which is, in most of the case, reaching certain ages, you have no legal capacity to make any decisions.

It is also uncertain if you are still a minor or not.

This voids the "paper" you have signed.

2. The nature of the "paper"

The "paper" is not a legal agreement, or at best, an unilateral agreement. For an agreement to be legally bound, certain conditions must be met, such as fair exchange in value. In this case, you are "gifting" the property interest. It will be difficult to enforce this "paper" as a legally bound contract.

3. Undue influence and Intention to defraud

Based on your information, your aunt picked the wrong place and the wrong time to discuss the issue (as you are under influence by the death of your relatives).

Your aunt's act is intentional and planned, which can be explained by the "paper".

4. Inability to Enforce

Although your aunt plotted the whole scheme, the actual beneficiary in this case is her daughter. Only her daughter, if not a minor, can raise legal challenge. Your aunt has no standing in this case.

(In the case of a minor, the whole "paper" is voided again as she has no capacity to accept such gift.)

In conclusion, you can simply ignore the whole thing. It is unlikely your aunt to challenge this in a court of law, as this has absolutely no chance to succeed.

But still, you still have to figure it what to do with that 50% interest.
2015-05-08 6:34 am
你既然簽了名,又有人作證,文件便產生法律作用.
你目前之計,是尋求法律解決.民建聯,公民黨,民主黨等議員,都有免費法律諮詢服務,你可致電給任何一個議員,請求協助,由他們代你安排一位律師見面,談談解決的方法.


收錄日期: 2021-04-15 20:12:57
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20150507000051KK00109

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份