詢問一下有關英文tense 問題

2015-03-19 5:18 am
當我準備離開Apple 百貨公司個陣,諗起頭先visit 間百貨公司,間公司好大,有不同種類既產品,咁當一離開百貨公司個陣講"I have visited Apple Department Store. It was big. There were different kinds of products in the department store." 想問問大家d句子既時態有無錯。

(註:我係由Apple 百貨公司既最高既層離開Apple 百貨)

回答 (4)

2015-03-19 10:38 am
✔ 最佳答案
I won't mix Present Perfect tense with Simple Past tense with the same context of describing events.

當一離開百貨公司個陣講, you can say:
I have just been to Apple Department Store. It is big. There are different kinds of products in the store.

In distant past, you can say:
I visited Apple Department Store (three months ago, last year, in 1997). It was big. There were different kinds of products in the store.

2015-03-19 02:40:06 補充:
typo: I won't mix Present Perfect tense with Simple Past tense "within" the same context of describing events.
2015-03-19 6:42 pm
句子的寫/講法除了文法結構之外,亦要考慮你說的用詞和用意的。
當你離開時講你"visit"其實無論文法或現實邏輯上"visit"都是過去發生了的"動作",所以你用have visited(好像是想表達"剛去過")其實在英語表達的習慣上不會這樣講/寫,而是直接用過去式visited來表達"已經去完了"...接下去的內容你講在這"去完了的地方"情形用過去式便正確。

I visited Apple Department Store. It was big and there were different kinds of products in it.

修改連接和用一些可用代名詞(不用每句都話the department store).
2015-03-19 10:23 am
Don't really get what you mean in chinese though.

By the time i left the apple department store, the first impression is big and there are different variety of goods.
參考: myself
2015-03-19 5:26 am
應該沒有錯吧!我不知道
參考: 自己


收錄日期: 2021-04-11 21:02:06
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20150318000051KK00102

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份