有關現在進行式問題一問

2014-11-16 5:46 am
Tom 同我講"What is Mary doing now?" 於是我望一望Mary ,她正在洗碟,於是我答"Mary is washing dishes."假設當我講這句子"Mary is washing dishes." 講到一半時,Mary 突然停止洗碟,我係米無需要再講埋該句子餘下部分。

回答 (3)

2014-11-16 5:59 am
✔ 最佳答案
我理解你發問的意思。

但我覺得不要這樣執著,你可以選擇完成你的句子:
Mary is washing dishes (now).

也可以不再說下去,因為當時 Mary 已經停止洗碟。

你這個情況雖說是你的執著,但日常生活也會經常遇到。

例如新聞報導員在報導即時的股價,很多時候正當他們在說的時候,股價就變動了。那麼作出即時修正就可以了。

因此,你也不必太擔心。
你可以先完成你的句子,再補充一句:
Mary has just stopped washing dishes.


2014-11-20 04:00:50 補充:
加油吧!

╭∧---∧╮
│ .✪‿✪ │
╰/) ⋈ (\\╯
2014-11-20 11:57 am
Leo:
你無需要再講埋該句子餘下部分, 正如"知足常樂"說, 不要這樣執著

如果餘下部分是這樣, (我 make up 句子 for illustration) 講埋無傷大雅
Mary is washing dishes. She always helps her Mom.

同意知足常樂 ( 知識長 ) 的觀點

2014-11-22 03:35:20 補充:
TOMING88

You wrote, "She was stopped by Tom for watching" ~ passive voice
轉回 active voice, Tom stopped her for watching.
Did you mean Tom stopped her?
Who was watching? She or Tom?

I'm too embarrassed to point out all your mistakes.
Don't get annoyed. That's what you wrote.
2014-11-16 5:37 pm
The characters:-Tom---->Leo----> Mary;
The tense:-past continuous + past perfect;
stop=to no longer wash=eg :-She was stopped by Tom for watching.
embarrassment=shy, awkward, guilty feelings; feeling of being embarrassed;
Mary was washing dishes but was stopped for the embarrassent in your watching.(your=Tom).
"but" conj. is used to introduce an idea that contrasts with what was talked before:-eg:-Mary was washing. It wasn't now "but" stopped !
You try to contrast with what was said before to complete the part of the sentence.Okay ?

2014-11-20 08:30:03 補充:
Amendment:(1)Mary is washing dishes--(present continuous ;her action now)
(2)Mary has just stopped washing dishes (xx___)---(present perfect,1/2 action,1/2 completed) ; (To illustrate Leo's point, to illustrate what Leo means, eg:-The incident washing dishes illustrates the need for a better Mary)

2014-11-22 07:16:51 補充:
propose amendment:-She was stopped washing dishes by Tom's supervisory role on her washing.Hence:-She wss stopped (washing) by Tom's (supervisory role).Thanks.


收錄日期: 2021-04-11 20:51:27
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20141115000051KK00075

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份