tenses f.1 QUICK HELP PLS

2014-10-29 6:27 am
She likes painting.She takes painting lessons every saturday,but she _____ (not/have ) lessons this month because her teacher ________(travel ) in Europe.





why : pls and must explain!
thanks

回答 (4)

2014-10-29 6:34 am
✔ 最佳答案
我認為以下兩個情況也合理。


(1) 考慮未發生的情況:

She likes painting. She takes painting lessons every Saturday, but she will not have (not/have) lessons this month because her teacher will travel (travel) in Europe.
她喜愛繪畫。她逢星期六都會上繪畫班,但她這個月將不會上課,因為她的老師會到歐洲旅遊。


(2) 考慮已過去的情況:

She likes painting. She takes painting lessons every Saturday, but she did not have (not/have) lessons this month because her teacher travelled (travel) in Europe.
她喜愛繪畫。她逢星期六都會上繪畫班,但她這個月沒有上課,因為她的老師去了歐洲旅遊。


2014-10-28 22:50:23 補充:
如果用你的答案來「夾硬」解釋番轉頭,你可以話由於句子首部份用了 present tense,所以整句也跟著用 present tense 的模式。

因此,this month(視為一般情況) she does not have lessons,是因為她的老師正在外遊(用 present continuous tense),即 her teacher is travelling in Europe.

但其實我不是太同意。
也看看其他網友的意見...

﹝。◕‿◕。◕‿◠。﹞

2014-10-28 23:40:33 補充:
我個人覺得其實你用 is not having lessons 都可以的。
因為 near future 都可以用 present continuous tense。
我會放一點參考在意見欄。

但有可能其他網友不同意,我們也等待一下看看他們的意見。

2014-10-28 23:41:08 補充:
http://www.englishpage.com/verbpage/presentcontinuous.html

Present Continuous

USE 1 Now
USE 2 Longer Actions in Progress Now
USE 3 Near Future
USE 4 Repetition and Irritation with "Always"

2014-10-28 23:41:32 補充:
http://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/en/english-grammar/verbs/present-tense/present-continuous

http://www.eclecticenglish.com/grammar/PresentContinuous1A.html

http://www.englishtenses.com/tenses/present_continuous

2014-10-29 01:31:54 補充:
Thank you Dustin.

2014-10-30 22:52:16 補充:
多謝你 Godfrey。
2014-10-31 6:15 am
請留意前句子是 Present simple. (likes, takes) 談論是現在的事 (regular 常做)
this month 多數講 present
have 是 transitive verb, (可作state verb) 多數不用 continuous tense, 除了特別強調現在這一刻 action
I am having lunch now,
Have 這個字不同 travel
“is travelling “是講這段時期 (this month) 正在旅行
2014-10-31 1:57 am
the first answer is (doesn't have / does not have ), and the second answer i don't know'sorry!
2014-10-29 9:17 am
我認為關鍵是 time reference "this month".

If "next" or "last" is used instead, there is no question about using 未來式 或 過去式 respectively.

講話時間 could be anytime of the month. It'll never be wrong to refer it as "current" situation. (or sth true for this month)


收錄日期: 2021-04-11 20:54:23
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20141028000051KK00130

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份