香港永久性居民其實係冇中國國籍?

2014-10-20 8:19 am
香港永久性居民其實係冇中國國籍,
大家手上所拎住既香港特區護照其實冇講過香港人係持有中國國籍,
這只是一本旅遊證件而已, 換句話說你去到其他國家出左任何事,
理論上中國領事館係冇任何責任保護你,
事實上香港永久性居民係連申請中國護照的資格都沒有.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zOZsgfLq-w8
3:30開始

請問以上的論述可有憑證? 求香港/內地律師解答

回答 (3)

2014-10-25 5:36 pm
✔ 最佳答案

香港永久性居民只是表示其擁有香港居留權,沒有國籍意義。不過香港永久性居民絕大部份都是中國公民。


部份外國人士成為香港永久性居民但沒有歸化中國國籍者就不能申請特區護照。


也有難民好像來自越南及非洲等的獲香港收容而成為香港永久性居民,有的拒絕歸化中國國籍,變成無國籍,當然也不能申請特區護照。


不過要注意的是,所謂中國國籍的香港永久性居民,也只是香港入境處的記錄,不會通報大陸,進出大陸須申請回鄉卡,雖然名義上是中國公民,不過跟大陸居民不同,是"境外人士",在大陸入住酒店也須跟外國人一樣填報境外人士入住登記表。


2014-10-20 7:32 pm
"香港永久性居民其實係冇中國國籍"

應該說香港永久性居民,並不是全部是中國籍;因外國人居港滿 7年也可成為永久居民(外傭除外),但不是中國籍;


"大家手上所拎住既香港特區護照其實冇講過香港人係持有中國國籍,"

不正確;申領特區護照必需符合三項條件,缺一不可:是中國公民;是香港特別行政區永久性居民;及持有有效的香港永久性居民身份證

"這只是一本旅遊證件而已, 換句話說你去到其他國家出左任何事, 理論上中國領事館係冇任何責任保護你"

不正確; "如你是香港居民並擁有中國公民身分,在境外遇上困難而需要協助時,中華人民共和國駐外的使、領館可以提供協助"
入境處頁:http://www.gov.hk/tc/residents/immigration/outsidehk/assisttravel.htm



" 事實上香港永久性居民係連申請中國護照的資格都沒有".

正確;中國是不受理香港永久居民身份證持有人,申領中華 人民共和國護照的;
中國外交部駐香港特派員公署網頁, 一(4);
http://www.fmcoprc.gov.hk/chn/fw/zgrzj/t54803.htm

2014-10-20 3:32 pm
Most of them are false.

1. "香港永久性居民其實係冇中國國籍"

False. Many Permanent Residents are Chinese citizens, but not all of them. A few exceptions are:

a. Those who have renounced the citizenship;

b. Those who are not Chinese-descent and have granted British citizenship through British Nationality (Hong Kong) Act, 1997.

2. "大家手上所拎住既香港特區護照其實冇講過香港人係持有中國國籍"

No. The Identification page says the holder is a Chinese:

http://www.gov.hk/en/residents/immigration/images/personal.jpg

3. "這只是一本旅遊證件而已, 換句話說你去到其他國家出左任何事,
理論上中國領事館係冇任何責任保護你"

False. At the least, if you have lost your "travel document" in a foreign country, the Chinese embassies and consulates will need to issue a "travel document" for you to exit the country. However, they have no obligation when you are in a country that you also hold the nationality.

4. "事實上香港永久性居民係連申請中國護照的資格都沒有"

HKSAR Passport is a form of Chinese Passport, issued by the Immigration Department under the authority of Central Government.

5. "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zOZsgfLq-w8 3:30開始"

This audio was originated in 2008 (uploaded this year).

a. Russia Federation granted visa-free travel to HKSAR Passport holders in 2009 without the involvement of the Central Government:

http://www.info.gov.hk/gia/general/200906/03/P200906030161.htm

Since 2012. Chinese (Mainland) Passport holders can only travel visa-free in a group tour:

http://www.russia.org.cn/chn/2733/31295140.html

b. The U.K. has never explicitly granted right to abode to BDTC or BN(O) Passport holders. See here for the detail:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_British_nationality_law#Commonwealth_Immigrants_Acts

c. Hong Kong does not recognize multiple nationalities, but allows. See here:

http://www.basiclaw.gov.hk/tc/basiclawtext/images/basiclawtext_doc15.pdf

d. Here is the list of cases at the International Court of Justice at the Hague:

http://www.icj-cij.org/docket/index.php?p1=3&p2=2

Only 2 cases related to the U.K. and none of them involved nationality.

(European Court of Justice is located at Luxembourg.)

收錄日期: 2021-04-15 16:52:15
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20141020000051KK00002

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份