I have a friend of mine and I'm kinda keen on trying to figure him out
He refuses to take the test sincehe thinks they all are fake and proven to be wrong, quite stubborn and though usually calm if he feels like his friends don't respect his opinion or show signs of weakness he becomes quite, quite bitter
He's definitelly either INTJ or ISTJ, an intelligent, cold, reserved...
The main question is if he is N or S?
On one hand he is very details-obsessed and never accepts anything unless it's proven hence S
But he is also very creative, likes new approaches and innovative thinking hence S
A friend - INTJ or ISTJ?
2014-09-26 8:49 pm
回答 (4)
2014-11-01 12:48 am
The test aren't all that accurate in determining one's mbti type. Also, nobody will posses 100% of any type's traits. A more efficient way of identifying your friend's main type is to thoroughly study the eight cognitive functions. For a very simplified description of them, look for my post here (ignore the irrelevant info): https://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20141015142032AA2ra9O
INTJ: dominant Ni, auxiliary Te, tertiary Fi, Inferior Se
ISTJ: dominant Si, auxiliary Te, tertiary Fi, Inferior Ne
Introverted intuition dominant INTJ lives in a world of far-reaching implications, underlying meanings, patterns, connections, insights, and symbols.
Introverted sensing dominant ISTJ lives in world of nostalgia, sentiments, impressions, and memories.
So stereotypically...
Both the INTJ and ISTJ utilize execution-style, results-oriented thinking to make their plans and ideas come into a reality (auxiliary Te). They see the logical stepping stones they need to progress through in order to achieve a goal and strive for the practical application of their knowledge. They have relative difficulty expressing their emotions and forming personal value judgments independent of predetermined "codes (aka rules)" for behavior (tertiary Fi).
However, the ISTJ is better at recalling concrete sensory, tangible facts in their literal form than an INTJ, giving him a tight, precise grip of the physical aspects of reality (dominant Si). ISTJ is more prone to becoming sentimental and nostalgic. The INTJ is better at making associations and connections between events, which bestow upon him depth of understanding and foresight (dominant Ni). The ISTJ has a difficult time creatively imagining possibilities, thinking outside the box, and embracing change (inferior Ne). The INTJ is predisposed to feel overwhelmed with loads of sensory information, so therefore, has a comparatively hard time purely engaging in his five senses and will need to rely on his intellect for comfort (inferior Se). The ISTJ is past oriented, the INTJ is future oriented. The ISTJ has a conventional, traditional view of life. The INTJ has an unconventional, conceptual view of life.
INTJ: dominant Ni, auxiliary Te, tertiary Fi, Inferior Se
ISTJ: dominant Si, auxiliary Te, tertiary Fi, Inferior Ne
Introverted intuition dominant INTJ lives in a world of far-reaching implications, underlying meanings, patterns, connections, insights, and symbols.
Introverted sensing dominant ISTJ lives in world of nostalgia, sentiments, impressions, and memories.
So stereotypically...
Both the INTJ and ISTJ utilize execution-style, results-oriented thinking to make their plans and ideas come into a reality (auxiliary Te). They see the logical stepping stones they need to progress through in order to achieve a goal and strive for the practical application of their knowledge. They have relative difficulty expressing their emotions and forming personal value judgments independent of predetermined "codes (aka rules)" for behavior (tertiary Fi).
However, the ISTJ is better at recalling concrete sensory, tangible facts in their literal form than an INTJ, giving him a tight, precise grip of the physical aspects of reality (dominant Si). ISTJ is more prone to becoming sentimental and nostalgic. The INTJ is better at making associations and connections between events, which bestow upon him depth of understanding and foresight (dominant Ni). The ISTJ has a difficult time creatively imagining possibilities, thinking outside the box, and embracing change (inferior Ne). The INTJ is predisposed to feel overwhelmed with loads of sensory information, so therefore, has a comparatively hard time purely engaging in his five senses and will need to rely on his intellect for comfort (inferior Se). The ISTJ is past oriented, the INTJ is future oriented. The ISTJ has a conventional, traditional view of life. The INTJ has an unconventional, conceptual view of life.
參考: Personality Tests are WRONG!: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pSNTdSSLauQ
Function Order Diagram: https://cezarspace.files.wordpress.com/2014/02/mbti-functions-map.png
Ni vs. Ne: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vi74ixXyGY8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=USzPndBNLbM
Si vs. Se: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y5TYzazDq80
INTJ vs ISTJ: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nDIEW5b2Gyo
2014-09-26 9:05 pm
If you can't help me in this analysis, don't well, spam this discussion with some worthless trolling please
2014-09-26 8:57 pm
Then that's your issue.
2014-09-26 8:51 pm
Does it matter. He's only a friend. It's not like you're going to marry him.
收錄日期: 2021-04-15 18:49:21
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20140926124944AAWRnEf