事情是這樣的,一個女子於2003年在福建同一名男子A君在內地結婚,大概年半後A君自己向女子提出單方面離婚,而女子接受並且沒有追問結果,在2005年同男子B君於香港註冊結婚,B君之後拿到香港身份証,亦提出離婚,女子於2009年同年被入境署問話,最後得知原來因為A君沒有單方面離婚攪到女子重婚,最後冇被起訴,1年後B君亦被入境署問話,同樣沒有被起訴.B君剛剛上個月突然收到(屯門清山灣入境署)的電話,告訴他有關他居港權事宜需商討以及有一些文件比佢睇,於是B君帶同律師到屯門清山灣入境署了解情況~去到既時候只係有一名職員告訴他{第一:因為你前妻和你結婚時係重婚,即係你的身份証係非法的,第二:既然你們離左婚,相信你在香港並沒有親人需要你照顧,中國以取消你的居港權,現在請B君你自動放棄居港權返回內地,時限1個月比B君考慮~但入境署完全沒有任何相關法律文件証明比B君睇~
問1:重婚問題以是2009年之前的事,當時不起訴,現在可告番轉頭?
問2:B君經過咁多部門的審核先拿到身份証,他在香港生活以5年,可以因為當時女方重婚而撤銷居留權?
謝謝
高手請幫忙:有關居港權
2014-06-01 8:08 pm
回答 (2)
2014-06-02 1:09 am
✔ 最佳答案
1. The Immigration Department can if new evidence arises.Please note - A and B are parties of interest. The wife is the actual target of prosecution.
2. The answer is unfortunately yes - Immigration Department is correct.
The marriage between the wife and B is invalid at the very beginning. So B's application for residence has bee misrepresented (Immigration Department could prosecute this case as fraud. But apparently, the Department chose not to do so). Based on this, the residence is invalid as well.
Director of Immigration has discretionary authority to grant residence. However, since B is not currently married to a Hong Kong Permanent Resident, there is no compelling reason for the Director to invoke this authority.
Voluntary Departure is a discretion already by the Department (as they could detain and deport immediately).
B can try judicial review. But it is unlikely to succeed.
2014-06-02 16:39:03 補充：
1. They can do so. The only problem is the true intent of the Immigration Department. Beside, there was a lawyer with B when B appeared at the Immigration Department. This means Immigration Department is not bluffing.
2014-06-02 16:39:39 補充：
So even getting married may allow the Director to invoke discretionary authority, the Immigration Department can go back to the issue with polygamy again.
2014-06-02 16:41:44 補充：
2. Why don't I put it this way - B has no legal basis at all, even the Court of Final Appeal will not even help.
I said B can try judicial review. I did not said the chance is good (the success chance is less than 10%).
2014-06-04 11:17:18 補充：
1. Yes.
2. Then it will become a deportation case. Immigration Department will go to B's residence and arrest B on the spot and arrange next available bus back to Mainland.
If no immediate arrangement, B will be detained in an Immigration Department Detention facility, similar to jail.
2014-06-04 11:18:01 補充：
Even B may escape from the Immigration Department, his HKID will be flagged and any police will arrest on the spot given the deportation order.
2014-06-02 6:51 pm
這一情況,最好先尋求法律意見,再作決定.民建聯及民主黨等政黨,都有免費的法律諮詢服務,可先致電他們,約時面晤,查詢一切,必要時,可請之介紹律師以處理有關事宜.但要先弄清有關的收費始可決定.
收錄日期: 2021-04-14 00:05:02
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20140601000051KK00054