Do people who hate socialism refuse to call the police or fire department?
2014-05-18 2:40 am
Out of their principled disdain for government services provided to all citizens equally, paid for by taxes collected from all.
回答 (15)
2014-05-18 2:44 am
✔ 最佳答案
Do people who hate capitalism throw their computers out the window, make their own clothes from plants, and not work for a private company?
2014-05-18 2:41 am
Don't be ridiculous.
So Kenji according to your own liberal logic:
People who hate Capitalism should refuse to shop at grocery stores and watch TV!
Out of their principled disdain for private sector capitalism provided to all citizens equally, and paid for by the people that use it.
See the socialism I hate is when the government does not give me a choice, like paying into SS, unemployment, forcing me to believe in and and pay for abortions and man-made global warming.
Now you may have a point, because the government is trying to stop me from defending myself, so I must depend on the government police that put you on hold when you call 911.
Quit forcing me to pay for government cops and fire and I will defend myself, or call private security or private fire department for much less money.
So Kenji according to your own liberal logic:
People who hate Capitalism should refuse to shop at grocery stores and watch TV!
Out of their principled disdain for private sector capitalism provided to all citizens equally, and paid for by the people that use it.
See the socialism I hate is when the government does not give me a choice, like paying into SS, unemployment, forcing me to believe in and and pay for abortions and man-made global warming.
Now you may have a point, because the government is trying to stop me from defending myself, so I must depend on the government police that put you on hold when you call 911.
Quit forcing me to pay for government cops and fire and I will defend myself, or call private security or private fire department for much less money.
2014-05-18 2:41 am
Apples and oranges....
city services are paid by PROPERTY TAXES... not income...
And capitalism, and by extension wealth, hasnt a damn thing to do with it...
city services are paid by PROPERTY TAXES... not income...
And capitalism, and by extension wealth, hasnt a damn thing to do with it...
2014-05-18 2:46 am
We used to not have fire departments in our towns and cities. We used to have to pay, and when we did, they would install a placard near our front door. If our house caught on fire and we had the placard, they would put out the fire. If we didn't have the placard, they'd roast marshmallows.
Thankfully, we have socialized fire departments but you can still hire special private units to protect your house specifically in areas where wild fires are common.
The battle isn't over socialism as much as it's over how much socialism is correct for America. Less than Scandinavia apparently.
Thankfully, we have socialized fire departments but you can still hire special private units to protect your house specifically in areas where wild fires are common.
The battle isn't over socialism as much as it's over how much socialism is correct for America. Less than Scandinavia apparently.
2014-05-18 2:49 am
You don't understand what socialism is. It's public ownership to some degree of the means of manufacturing. One of the proper roles of government is the protection of rights and liberties of it's citizens. Police and fire are services that should be supplied by government.
2014-05-18 2:49 am
The argument is beyond absurd.
But still, quite typical of the left.
"Socialism, like the ancient ideas from which it springs, confuses the distinction between government and society. As a result of this, every time we object to a thing being done by government, the socialists conclude that we object to its being done at all." - Frédéric Bastiat
To oppose big, intrusive, oppressive government does not mean one opposes local police.
But still, quite typical of the left.
"Socialism, like the ancient ideas from which it springs, confuses the distinction between government and society. As a result of this, every time we object to a thing being done by government, the socialists conclude that we object to its being done at all." - Frédéric Bastiat
To oppose big, intrusive, oppressive government does not mean one opposes local police.
2014-05-18 2:45 am
They've already been forced to pay for it ....give us an opt-out and we will gladly exercise it
2014-05-18 2:42 am
They represent me on the lines through taxation. In California that takes a big bite out of my check. Every time a California Highway patrol officer writes a ticket for expired registration they get a raise practically.
2014-05-18 7:02 am
Most of them have not the slightest idea of what socialism is. It's just a fashionable insult.
2014-05-18 2:50 am
for the same reason
2014-05-18 3:23 am
That weak argument is overused and still does not make sense.
Police and fire departments existed long before the idea of socialism was ever pondered.
Police and fire departments existed long before the idea of socialism was ever pondered.
2014-05-18 3:07 am
the police or fire department are not socialist programs
2014-05-18 2:56 am
So simple minded. We don't have a police department and our fire department is 100% volunteer (all 7 of them). There's a whole, big, wide world different from the one you live in out there.
2014-05-18 2:47 am
They are paid thru property taxes and this sort of thing, welfare comes directly out of my pay check before I even get to see it!
2014-05-18 2:43 am
The police are an extention of the mafia.
Their unions extort the working class due to their evil greed and corruption.
Their unions extort the working class due to their evil greed and corruption.
收錄日期: 2021-04-21 00:04:18
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20140517184013AAqGt17