比較級文法問題:as BeV+S ????

2014-01-17 4:44 am
在作文法書的題庫的時候發現這一題:
Taipei is approximately eight times as far from Kaohsiung _______.
(A)than is Tainan
(B)than Tainan is
(C)as is Tainan
(D)is as Tainan

↑本題小弟選(B),可是正確答案是(C),(C)看起來感覺怪怪的呀~~!!!???可不可以幫小弟解釋一下為何是(C)呢??

回答 (3)

2014-01-17 7:29 pm
✔ 最佳答案
連接詞as與such, the same, as或so等字搭配使用時,與關係代名詞一樣兼具代名詞的功能,因此稱為[準關係代名詞]。

Thompson was as good a basketball player as has ever played the game.
第二個as是準關係代名詞,as = a basketball player

We will give the audience such a show as has never been seen before.
as = a show

The girl wore the same red dress as her mother did.
as = the red dress

以上說明及例句取自LiveABC編<英文文法完全攻略p.281

Taipei is approximately eight times as far from Kaohsiung as is Tainan.
是錯誤的,因為第二個as如果當[準關係代名詞]用,在as ... as之間沒有名詞可當其先行詞。
所以本句只能寫成Taipei is approximated eight times as far from Kaohsiung as Tainan.
你的題庫有問題,未提供正確答案給你選。

類似的n times as ... as句子如下(取材自趙振才編<英語常見問題大詞典>pp.95-96):
This airplane flies two times as fast as that one.
He has five times as many books as you.
He is twice as strong as he was.(與前面的is時態不同,所以才保留was )
I have three times as much as I want.(want與have不同,才保留)




2014-01-17 11:50:06 補充:
We have undertaken to provide higher education for as many people as want it.
關係子句as want it修飾people,as是關係子句的主詞。many前面的as是副詞。

Are you thinking the same thing as I (am thinking)?
這個例句裡的as先行詞是thing,所以也可以用關係代名詞which,而不用as。

以上取自綿貫陽著<新觀念英文法>p.381準關係代名詞
2014-01-17 5:54 am
Taipei is approximately eight times as far from Kaohsiung __as is Tainan_____.

When you use "as" you cannot use "than". As ... as is used together. E.G. As far as I am concerned. it makes no difference. If you want to use a comparison, then Taipei is approximately eight times farther from Kaohsiung than Tainan.
參考: me
2014-01-17 5:10 am
因為as far的關係,所以後面要選as

你可以參考 http://www.ptt.cc/man/Eng-Class/D5A1/M.1131365512.A.6BE.html

如果你要選比較級,前面應該要是 farer than....

我沒有辦法說的很清楚,所以只發表意見,等高手解答嚕


收錄日期: 2021-05-01 16:35:16
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20140116000016KK03878

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份