香港老師沒收學生的手提電話犯法嗎?

2013-12-08 9:46 am
我早前係學校上堂個時被老師沒收手提電話,老師叫我叫家長黎拿番,同記缺點。感佢係沒收我部手提電話的時侯佢係米已經犯法?
要引用香港基本法法例作答!!

回答 (4)

2013-12-08 6:15 pm
✔ 最佳答案
學校是個教育機構,對學生有管教的責任,同時,亦有責任維持學校的紀律,你在上課時用手提電話,不但違犯校規,亦影響其他同學的學習.老師將之收下,,令你着家長取回,完全合法.除非老師沒收後將手提電話據為己有,你便可以向校長投訴處理,無論如何,法庭不會隨便處理學校內部的事
2013-12-08 5:30 pm
佢有話沒收你電話嗎﹖佢同你保管啫,叫你家長去攞,你咪照做囉,電話要緊,當然要攞.......................
2013-12-08 4:02 pm
1. No - forfeiture and detention is different.

Your phone is detained, not forfeited (Since your parents can get it back).

2. It may. However, since you are a minor, you have no legal right.

(If the school decides to hold the phone even with your parents' involvement, then it will be an issue.)
2013-12-08 10:26 am
no...mine is also...i mean my school also has this rule...thats the most normal thing in school ><

收錄日期: 2021-04-13 19:50:20
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20131208000051KK00018

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份