寫研究院的推薦信應找誰人?

2013-11-30 2:14 am
想申請本地大學的doctoral degree,聽說推薦信很重要,請問推薦信的推薦人是否以有Dr. 銜頭的教授為佳?

email 其中兩位曾被任教Dr. 銜頭的Professor,他們在我諗的master 課程時任教的科目比較多對我能力比較認識,但給他們的查詢email 皆石沉大海無回音,現正想找另兩位教授,但他們的銜頭只是MA,MFA 的Associate Professor,我與他們比較稔熟,應該會答應幫忙,但不知doctoral degree 的推薦信找沒有PHD 學位的教授是否不大有說服力,而且,其中一個也在兩年前退休了!申請這doctoral degree 要寫research proposal 申請已覺很考驗,現在推薦信又一難關,想死!

請有相關經驗的人指點!
更新1:

我問題的重點不埋怨,而是遇到問題找alternatives 時想有人提意見,慨嘆申請時解決的問題要很多,不是要謾罵,請了解清楚一下人家的說話才評論吧!說人家沒質素的人也不見得有多少質素。

更新2:

Thanks Gary, I understand what you mean. You give me the perspectives other than the one I search in the internet.

回答 (3)

2013-11-30 9:47 pm
✔ 最佳答案
Your focus is wrong.

1. Usually job title (tenure) is better than academic qualification, as the title reflects teaching and research experience, but the academic qualification can still mean nothing.

2. Your key for admission is the research plan. Unlike undergraduate studies, you must know what you want before you apply for your doctorate program. So your research plan should show that.

3. Recommendation letters, although required, usually only as a reference.

You should simply focus on presenting yourself.



2013-12-01 03:58:22 補充:
Just make sure - you have to know what you want.

Recommendation letters has an impact to your application, but not as strong as you think.
2013-12-05 2:22 am
周星馳是一個不錯的選擇 (^(00)^)
參考: me
2013-11-30 7:38 pm
如果你連寫 research proposal 都吽吽聲,你都係唔好讀好過。因為讀博士大把 paper 要寫。最後重要寫 dissertation,到時你咪真係想死?

大大話話,你都係碩士,竟然連搵乜人寫 recommendation letter 都唔知,乜而家 d 教育剩係訓練出 d 書呆子?算罷啦!


收錄日期: 2021-04-20 14:34:13
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20131129000051KK00119

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份