家居閉路電視是否違法?

2013-10-19 7:23 pm
本人身住居屋, 我想問鄰居妣 BB 安全為由,裝CCTV , 但是未經管理處批准, 是否屬於違規及侵犯私隱權? 想問有咩條例可以定他罪?

要專業人士解答, PLZ
更新1:

本人身住居屋, 我想問鄰居為 BB 安全為由,裝了2部針孔CCTV , 但是未經管理處批准, 是否屬於違規及侵犯私隱權? 想問有咩條例可以定他罪? 要專業人士解答, PLZ

回答 (3)

2013-10-19 8:10 pm
✔ 最佳答案
門口走廊通道均屬公共地方不含私穩權條例所限~~~


人家以家居保安為由可以合理在家門按裝視像攝錄監察系統 ^^

何況你明知人家是以bb安全為由,
就請勿小題大造吧 ~-^



.....
2013-10-19 10:14 pm
If you truly want professionals, then you are in the wrong place.

(Professional opinion is not free).

However, in answering your question, privacy is not the issue in this case.

The actual issue is against the deed of the property.

In this case, the best way is to ask the management company to take actions. If your neighbour fails to do so, you can ask the court to force the removal.

Your neighbour does not violate any Hong Kong Ordinance. In a common law system, a person can sue or be sued even no ordinance has been violated (like breach of contract or violation of case law).
2013-10-19 8:06 pm
你寫明要專業人士解答,咁我就唔係,所以呢方面既問題就無謂答你,不過咁,你講到要入佢罪就好困難,因為就算佢錯哂,都只係拆番就可以,未去到要定罪咁大件事.

2013-10-19 12:11:40 補充:
同埋仲有一樣野提下你,裝cctv其實就冇邊條法例可以直接入罪,大至上有2個形式可以算係有關連,一係建築物條例,二係私隱條例.前者就好難去搵到有咩地方會犯規,後者就要涉及收集資料既層面,例如佢只係影低而無錄低,法理上都冇問題.

希望有專業人士可以幫到你.

2013-10-19 23:33:30 補充:
Gary:Professional opinion is not free

呢句無得頂!好野!

收錄日期: 2021-04-20 14:26:02
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20131019000051KK00071

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份