Chicago vs. New York: A realistic perspective?

2013-10-08 5:24 pm
Throughout my life, I have constantly debated the above questions, both for commercial reasons, and general enjoyment of the city atmosphere and its charisma.

First off, I am a junior is high school, and thus, trying as difficult as it is, to conform to a college / university. Currently, I live in Indianapolis, which is a great city (very friendly and pleasant) and all...but pales in comparison to such cities like New York and Chicago. Almost, as if it is a city on training wheels.

LA is out of the question. Though it pertains to cinema better, and though I have indeed visited the city, I just didn't like it...too far away, and not as majestic as it so greatly seemed. No offense to you LA locals, but it didn't really call my name so to speak.

My hopeful interests of study are roughly as follows (and of course, subject to change):
Cinema & Film production, animation/editing/sound design, video-game developing, architecture, flight-engineering and/or piloting, programming, and business internships.

For colleges, I am still in debate. NYU has been a potential candidate I have considered...but a question sharply comes to my mind: Is it too massive? Intimidating? Non-personal, or alienating? I am a very introverted person. However, I have come to believe it is an excellent place for anything an individual seeks, especially the interests I have listed above.

The U. of Chicago is out of the picture...$41K/year is sky-high financially. Please, leave suggestions of any other Chicago Universities that might fit my situation better.

Also, the debate to reside in my own state: IU, Purdue, Ball State? It gives me a headache.

Would the trade off of moving to New York bee too daunting for a 19-year old entering college (I'm 17 now fyi)? Is there too much competition to enter a successful business position? I have the nerves to do it, that is a prime reason why I love big cities so much (though, I am extremely naive regarding NYC, as I can only make generalizations right now at least).

I hear Chicago is cleaner, friendlier, less dense (obviously), and of course, less expensive. Additionally, Chicago is only about a three hour drive from Indianapolis. What I can concur from my visits, is that Chicago is very elegant, polite, and cheaper, yet still offering tons of opportunity.

Is making 100K in NY really just "average" compared to smaller cities?

BUT, NY seems to have more opportunity for cinema like positions, as with engineering, architecture...and everything. To me, it makes Chicago look like an apprentice, NY being king. something I can never get out of my head; the idea that NY is the "capital of the world", the real deal.

Really, I can't make an accurate judgement as I never have been to NY. I would greatly appreciate what you friends think...especially the veteran NY-ers. More importantly, one who has been through careers and figured out the "system" of living there.

Same with you Chicago and Indiana folks...and everyone else who genuinely has been through many situations and is a keen observer of the matter.

All help is greatly appreciated.
更新1:

@MM : No, I'm not a hipster (I hope you are joking). Second, I am very naive, I am not trying to inflate what I already know to sound "sophisticated". In fact, NY kind of scares me. My question is really, living there after college, and whether going to a university THERE would show any difference to Chicago or a local, in-state college? I do understand your perspective, as you probably think of me as someone who doesn't really know adult life well, which is actually true a bit. That is where my question comes in.

回答 (2)

2013-10-08 7:37 pm
✔ 最佳答案
Where you go to college and where you end up living and working afterwards have nothing to do with each other. You do not need to go to college where you want to end up working.

For architecture, sound, film studies you should look at BSU
They have a great arch. department and the David Letterman media center is wonderful
You would get a good education at a fraction of the cost of any college in Chicago and NYC.

As a junior you and your parents should be going on college visits right now. Meet with admissions, the head of the department you want to major in, and get a tour of the campus.
2013-10-08 10:53 pm
"To me, it makes Chicago look like an apprentice"

Oh, yeah, you're Manhattan material all right. Or possibly Brooklyn hipster. Which is not fair to my New York friends and family who do not think their city is the center of the universe or that those of us not privileged to reside in its overpriced shoebox apartments are uncultured serfs. But given the painstaking effort you've gone to in this inquiry to make sure we all understand how sophisticated you are, I can't see you being happy anywhere else.

That said, if the University of Chicago - which has its own share of pretension - is too expensive for you, then so is NYU. You also haven't mentioned your stats, so it's hard to tell just how realistic those schools are for you, or what would be too much of a step down academically even if it's more affordable. And with interests that wide-ranging, you really might want to pick a focus (or at least narrow it down to two or three somewhat related ones) before you throw yourself into an environment where you can easily get lost in all the options available to you, and where people are not necessarily going to be all that sympathetic or helpful if you stumble.


收錄日期: 2021-04-20 23:50:04
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20131008092448AAPDhq6

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份