Can you be physically attracted to someone, but not get fairy tale vibes from them? Why?

Yes.
You can be madly in love with someone and find someone else physically attractive at the same time.
That does not mean that u dont love the perwon ur with or love him any less.
Physical attraction is pure chemistry. Let me explain:

Your body has receptors that react to certain hormones, pheromones if you want. You can't really "smell" them but it is actually the scent of the person, the smell of their skin, his sweat (believe it or not) that turns u on and attracts you. The higher the rates of pheromones released (compatible with ur receptors) the more u would feel physically attracted

you can be attracted to someone physically but not like them as a person...it's like porn stars...they're attractive and do all things that you want your wife, GF, etc to do to you but if you had the opportunity to date a porn star you'd pass up that opportunity in a heart beat because they don't have the same morals, etc that you'd want in a partner

Throughout your life you will be 'physically attracted' to many people. I don't quite know what you mean by 'fairy tale vibes', but think you are being unrealistic in your idea of true attraction.

You cant exspect "fairytale vibes" from guys.life is not a fairy tale or a fable.

I guess.. Maybe their personality turns you off and that is enough to not make you have those "butterflies" in your stomach..

Are you nervous? Or are you comfortable and you just think they're hot??
:)
Xoxo