A先生與B小姐於內地以三書六禮形式结婚，婚後二人沒有子女；A先生後到香港定居，B小姐向A先生提出你不如找另一名妻子，因為好難申請到香港，之前申請過幾次都唔得。之後，A先生與C小姐相識，不久A先生與C小姐在香港註冊结婚，當時，A先生沒有與B小姐離婚，A先生是取得B小姐同意下與C小姐结婚，B小姐向A先生承諾不會申請來港定居，而C小姐亦知道B小姐向A先生承諾不會申請來港定居才決定結婚。但B小姐後來申請到香港定居，在親人家中居住。A先生與C小姐仍是共同生活，育有子女。
(1)就以上案例，A先生行為是否構成重婚罪(A先生與C小姐是在香港一夫一妻制成立之後結婚)？如果C小姐不清楚香港有這個法律條例下與A先生結婚是否同樣構成重婚罪？如有證據顯示B小姐是在A先生與C小姐在香港註冊结婚之前已儲心積慮開始申請到港(例如從B小姐申請到港的文件日期)， 目的係想同A先生與C小姐共同生活，然後幫手湊A先生與C小姐的孩子，希望在A先生與C小姐心目中有地位。在法理上，B小姐是否違反承諾，A先生與C小姐會否減輕判刑？
(2)請問重婚罪在香港有沒有追訴權時效(以我所知，在台灣重婚罪的追訴權時效是20年)？B小姐現在是否仍有權向法庭提起訴訟？
(3)就以上案例，A先生與C小姐現在應該如何處理這個婚姻問題？尋求法律協助？離婚？請大家比一些專業意見？
(4)如果A先生過身，生前已訂立遺囑及將物業轉名給兒女。B小姐可否告A先生與C小姐重婚罪及從法律途俓取回A先生所有遺產及物業？ 如果A先生生前與C小姐離婚，同樣已訂立遺囑及將物業轉名給兒女，情況會否有不同？
歡迎具備專業法律知識的人士解答。
凡胡亂作答，會向Yahoo知識投訴。
有關香港重婚罪的問題，歡迎具備專業法律知識的人士解答。
2013-07-29 4:20 am
回答 (3)
2013-07-29 9:35 am
✔ 最佳答案
首先，樓主提及的要旨是：「A先生與B小姐於內地以三書六禮形式结婚」
中國法律是以地方法例為依歸，即是說各省各地各村可以是非常不同的，本人未知該地法例有否指明三書六禮已為法律認可。
然而，以本人的認知，三書六禮只屬禮教儀式，與我們香港「只擺酒、不註冊」是同樣沒有法律效力的。
因此第一、第二及第三條問題已無關。
第四條問題：
B小姐可否提出重婚控訴，藉已取回A先生所有遺產？
－－根據香港法律，如A先生生前已訂立遺囑，並指名遺繼繼承人為C小姐及兒女，而這份遺囑是合法的（「合法」的定義可能比較複雜，簡單來說，需找律師處理整個程序），B小姐便可根據法律承繼遺產。
即是說，假設A先生生前已被判重婚，也不影響B小姐的承繼，因遺產繼承人不一定要是夫婦關係。
以上回答的是根據香港法律。
參考: 法律知識
2013-07-30 12:31 am
Pls refer to 第178章 《婚姻制度改革條例》
2013-07-29 10:08 am
1. Not necessary.
The marriage of A and C is recognized. However, the marriage of A and B may not be recognized (If the marriage was formed after October 7, 1971, it was not recognized. If the marriage was before October 7, 1971, then additional steps were required for the marriage to be recognized).
Only the party involved in the bigamy (A) will be in trouble.
As bigamy is a criminal offense, others' intention won't matter.
2. In theory, no statute of limitation, given it is a criminal offense. As a criminal offense, only the HKSAR Government can bring charges against the parties.
B does not have the authority.
3. Ask this question - is the marriage of A and B recognized under the law?
If yes, the best way is to surrender with the Immigration Department (with a lawyer).
Divorce does not resolve the criminal issue of the bigamy.
If no, no issue at all.
4. No. A will is a will. Unless the will is found to be invalid, the court must follow the deceased's wish based on the will.
The marriage of A and C is recognized. However, the marriage of A and B may not be recognized (If the marriage was formed after October 7, 1971, it was not recognized. If the marriage was before October 7, 1971, then additional steps were required for the marriage to be recognized).
Only the party involved in the bigamy (A) will be in trouble.
As bigamy is a criminal offense, others' intention won't matter.
2. In theory, no statute of limitation, given it is a criminal offense. As a criminal offense, only the HKSAR Government can bring charges against the parties.
B does not have the authority.
3. Ask this question - is the marriage of A and B recognized under the law?
If yes, the best way is to surrender with the Immigration Department (with a lawyer).
Divorce does not resolve the criminal issue of the bigamy.
If no, no issue at all.
4. No. A will is a will. Unless the will is found to be invalid, the court must follow the deceased's wish based on the will.
收錄日期: 2021-04-29 22:49:07
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20130728000051KK00236