Okay, I've been trying to switch my cat over to wet food for a while now and it's just not working... She seems to hate just about anything and everything that's considered a healthy choice for wet food AND she's a little bit overweight [by ~1-2lbs according to the vet]. Which is one of the reasons I want to switch her over. She also seems to have Urinary Health issues, another reason I want to switch to wet.
I was thinking about trying to get her to eat Fancy Feast wet food at the very least because I've read that any kind of wet food is better than dry food. Would this be a good idea for now? If so, which of the wet FF's is the better choice? She hates pate style foods the most but she'll eat a little shredded/minced foods as long as there is gravy which I read was also bad because of high carbs...
Right now I'm feeding her Nutro Natural Choice, Indoor dry food. However the recommended amounts for a 12lb cat [Her current weight] say 1/2 cup per day. Since I'm trying to help her lose weight I've been feeding her the recommended amount for an 8lb cat [1/3 cup per day] since the chart completely skips 10lbs which is what the vet told me she should weigh. However she never completely finishes her food in one sitting or even the entire day. She's a nibbler, although I'm currently in the process of getting her on a feeding schedule too.
Twice per day is the goal.
I don't know how she can be overweight without ever fully finishing her meals... It worries me when she doesn't eat everything because I'm supposed to take away the food after about 15 to 20 minutes and then not feed her for another 8-12 hours. It doesn't seem like she's getting the amount of kcals she needs per day but is overweight at the same time!
BTW - I'm not looking for the answer Ken S provides everybody with when they ask questions like this. I already went over all that stuff and didn't get a CLEAR answer from any of it.
That's actually what made me second guess just trying to feed her wet FF with gravy... If I can find one she'll eat would it better to have her eat that rather than dry even it's not the best wet food out there?