以下案件會怎樣處理?

2013-03-26 10:12 am
假設有一對情侶,凌晨時份,男生送女生回家。這個時候,有一中年男子突然出現並撲向女生,正想侵犯並強暴女事主,男生想要保護女朋友,使她免受侵犯,就推開該中年男子。但就唔好彩,將佢推左落樓梯,個中年男人就死左。

咁呢件事會點處理?其中一個可能性就係判個男仔誤殺,但錯既係個中年男人想強姦佢女朋友,咁樣去推開個強姦犯係完全合情合理之舉,唔通企係格離報警睇住自己女朋友俾人搞完d警察都未黎到咁樣?咁樣判未免有d無理。就係咁樣既案件既話,警方會點處理?

個男仔一開始又應該點做先至可以唔會那屎上身?
更新1:

gary: so what if i could prove that im innocent? would i still be penalized whatsoever? 箭豬山: 仲話擅長領域係基督教,完全失見證-_- 問題重點係咁樣殺左人會唔會俾人告得入 我係十歲既咁你真係…唉唔講 收皮啦

更新2:

各位:問題重點係、咁樣殺左人會唔會俾人告得入、總之assume個男既係完全無辜 箭豬山: 你無諗到所有可能性、慳d

更新3:

箭豬山: 一、你都有問題,係條街度,做得出強姦緊係不能自制個d,有預謀既就唔會係條街到郁手啦係咪呀… 佢去強姦個女既做咩要綁住個男既?用腦、唔好用...唔該哂!智商不足我無辦法,但唔好係呢度(yahoo 知識)出現啦…呢d地方唔啱你的小朋友,返屋企玩啦! 二、仲有呢個唔係講緊我同我女朋友,我唔會攞我親人做例子,我給予佢地適當既尊重,我唔係你。不如你去驗眼?又或者唔識中文就唔好係度扮代表,咁既話香港可以更美好。 三、佢綁唔綁住我關我有無食藥、食左藥未咩事?你既邏輯思維有好大好大既問題…鄉下既農田較適合你去耕作,返去啦! 小朋友,記住用腦呀!

更新4:

箭豬山: 白痴個個係你,你張個重點完全理解錯左,個重點唔係佢跌落樓梯,重點係佢死左,呢度你已經錯左,加上你講咩佢條屍咩掂到咩撥開,你知唔知你自己講緊咩…可唔可以講野前先經大腦先打出黎,唔好用...諗野;講多次驚你唔記得左。 另外,諗唔通個個又係你,同上,此略。唔好扮醒啦fail 天真個個都係你,用腦啦。 你既智商、邏輯思維、諗野既位置同平常人都好唔同,真係…唉。 早抖啦

回答 (4)

2013-03-26 11:49 am
✔ 最佳答案
It is mostly self-defense.

The evidence should be able to prove it.

As a rapist, the person must have brought something to help him "finish" the tasks, like a weapon, a mask, etc.

These items are proof the rapist's intend, which can prove the boyfriend's need to self-defense.

2013-03-30 02:49:20 補充:
1. It is not you to prove anything. But the police must prove otherwise.

In other word, the police must prove that the killing is not justified in order to make you in trouble.

2. No if self-defense.

2013-03-30 02:50:15 補充:
The key is the evidence gathered from the rapist will be your best evidence from getting into trouble.
2013-04-05 12:21 pm
可以用類似"正當防禦"既理由
2013-03-28 4:40 pm
入罪講動機; 意圖; 目的. 罪重罪輕? 就要舉證到心態.
2013-03-27 1:48 am
突然出現並撲向女生,正想...侵犯並強暴....女事主

呢點係唔會成立既! 祗係你自已假想, 並無實則理據証明強姦.

你可以盡量將當時環境講出來.由法官去定斷.

警方亦會將你及你女友分開問話. 反覆問話係可以問出真相的. 你亦不能與女友夾口供. 普通人係九成九會露出破綻. 太完美又係會思疑.

總之, 真係有咁既事, 手尾都好長.





2013-03-26 17:53:06 補充:
再者...唔先綁住你, 而走去強姦你女友.......一係佢係白痴, 一係係你未食藥.

2013-03-26 18:00:22 補充:
又....如果真係將佢推左落樓梯,個中年男人就死左........若果唔係中環果條500尺長樓梯, 你多數冇事, 因為九成九佢死於本身隱疾!

2013-03-26 18:06:44 補充:
又或者係佢一早被人殺佐, 條屍響上層樓梯跌落黎, 碰到你女友, 你一手撥開左....都未定!!!

2013-03-27 17:09:46 補充:
如果係同同學吹吹水, 冇野搵野黎討論.....咁, 貼出黎就都要諗通D, 唔好咁天真!....

如果你係得十歲既小學生.......咁!....我向你道歉!

2013-03-30 08:02:19 補充:
哈哈! 係既 ! 係既 !

不如你話有個人響街頭想衝埋你女友度強姦佢, 重想姦埋你, 你望左佢一眼, 佢就死左! 咁點判重好啦!

2013-03-30 11:23:31 補充:
不過, 最重要既係我一時頑皮姐!...同你講下笑.....不過又好似好唔應該!

我向你道歉! SORRY!!

收錄日期: 2021-04-20 13:44:35
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20130326000051KK00023

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份