As if 文法

2012-07-29 3:01 am
I sat straight up as if just experienced a nightmare.
以上文法是否正確?
在PO文章時一位外國網友說這句應改成
I sat straight up as if I just experienced a nightmare.
網友是否正確?
更新1:

哇...好難選,都答的不錯 但Roger Cheng好像說中了...厲害...所以...

回答 (5)

2012-07-29 8:32 pm
✔ 最佳答案
I sat straight up as if I had just experienced a nightmare/
as if having just experienced a nightmare/
as if from a nightmare.
三個都可
你應該是要寫小說之類的吧(看那句子...)
第三個較適合
2012-07-29 6:49 am
I see nothing wrong with:

I sat straight up as if just experienced a nightmare.
I sat straight up as if had just experienced a nightmare.
I sat straight up as if just had a nightmare.
2012-07-29 6:17 am
as if 後面通常接子句
所以那個網友是對的~
PS: She opened her lips as if (she was going) to speak. 後面也可以接不定詞
參考: me
2012-07-29 3:33 am
I sat straight up as if I had just experienced a nightmare.
較早發生的事放在句子後面時,動詞應用過去完成式,表示比在前面的主要子句的過去簡單式動詞的時間較早。
2012-07-29 3:20 am
as if,是<副詞><連接詞>,引導<副詞子句 > 。<子句>中,可用現在式,以表示事實;也可用過去式或<過去完成式>,分別表示與現在或過去事實相反的<假設語氣>。

子句,應有主詞 。故你外國網友說這句應改成
I sat straight up as if I just experienced a nightmare .
網友是否正確?


正確!!


收錄日期: 2021-04-27 19:46:46
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20120728000015KK06037

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份