Question on English sentence

2012-07-15 2:29 pm
Should I use "was" or "is" and why?
If there are others mistakes, please also point it out. Thank you.

#############################################################
Mod House, which was/is??? a hospital in 10 years ago, is the only budget
accomodation for backpackers in Swan Town.

During April to October, which is the low season of apple picking, only a few
backpackers stay in the Mod House.

These people are normally working on pruning apple trees or planting blueberry tree.
#############################################################

回答 (4)

2012-07-15 3:24 pm
✔ 最佳答案
Correct tense and other mistakes

Mod House, which was a hospital (inX) 10 years ago, is the only budget accommodation (accomodation) for backpackers in Swan Town. - Use 'was' because Mod House was a hospital in the past. No preposition is needed before "10 years ago".
'accommodation' is the correct spelling.

During April to October, which is the low season of apple picking, only a few backpackers stay in the Mod House. - no mistakes

These people (areX) normally (workingX) work on pruning apple trees or planting blueberry trees(treeX). - Use simple present tense (not present continuous tense) to express that the action 'work' is usual. Use plural 'trees' for tree.

2012-07-15 07:25:41 補充:
accommodation (accomodationX)

2012-07-15 08:21:08 補充:
We can use present continuous tense for:
This month, which is in the low season of apple picking from April to October, only a few
backpackers are staying in the Mod House.These people are normally working on pruning apple trees or planting blueberry trees.

2012-07-15 08:29:56 補充:
Whereas both simple present and present continuous are correct grammatically, in the given sentences which do not specified the actions 'stay' and 'work' are happening now, stick to simple present tense for the actions in "usual" (or "general truth") sense.
2012-07-15 5:51 pm
In the past,Hospitals were built(=use past tense).
Delete (in) in phrase 10 years ago.
Accomodation spelling as :-accommodation.
As stated,the Past Continuous Tense is used for an action that is continuing but is expected to end sooner or later;end after a certain period of time for the apple picking season,hence:-
Mod House,which was a hospital 10 years ago,is the only budget accommodation for backpackers in Swan Town.
(adj.cl. of condition.)
參考: google website
2012-07-15 5:05 pm
Should I use "was" or "is" and why?
If there are others mistakes, please also point it out. Thank you.

Mod House, which wasa hospital 10 years ago, is the only budget
accomodation for backpackers in Swan Town.
= was (十年前的動作, 用past tense), ten years ago 前不用 in

During April to October, which is the low season of apple picking, only a few
backpackers stay in the Mod House. (正確)

These people are normally working on pruning apple trees or planting blueberry trees. (trees 眾數)

01 樓主, 連 present tense 和present continuous tense 的深層意義也不清楚, 要多查英文文法書!
2012-07-15 3:29 pm
Should I use "was" or "is" and why?
If there are others mistakes, please also point it out. Thank you.

Mod House, which was a hospital (delete in ) 10 years ago, is the only budget
accomodation for backpackers in Swan Town.
*** talking about 10 years ago , use the past tense - was

During April to October, which is the low season of apple picking, only a few
backpackers stay in the Mod House.
*** talking about general truth , use present tense

These people are normally working on pruning apple trees or planting blueberry trees. (plural form)


2012-07-15 07:39:20 補充:
#3****using present continuous tense is definitely correct grammatically because they are not working for the whole year, just one or two seasons. present continuous tense is used to show an action which will end after a certain period of time.
******It is wrong to use a present tense . I


收錄日期: 2021-04-20 13:02:43
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20120715000051KK00083

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份