完成進行式 和 進行式 的分別?

2012-05-04 9:36 am
我指是理解上會有什麼不同。
如︰
I have been doing it now.I am doing it now.
這兩句句子文法沒錯吧。沒錯的話,意思有什麼不同?如有錯請指出

回答 (4)

2012-05-05 1:19 am
✔ 最佳答案
回答者001(Yahoo!知識-管理員),這是英文文法題,回答時請自律不要離題,以身作則。

2012-05-04 17:19:59 補充:
完成進行式 和 進行式 的分別?

(現在,過去,未來)完成進行式 和 (現在,過去,未來)進行式 兩者都有進行中的意義,那麼分別在那?
現在進行式 Present continuous: is/am/are + present participle
The present continuous is used when the action is continuing now.
現在完成進行式 Present perfect continuous: Have/has + been + present participle
The present perfect continuous is used when the action is still continuing, and you wish to emphasize its duration.
To show the difference in emphasis, your examples should be:
I have been doing it for one hour.
I am doing it now. 過去/未來完成進行式 和過去/未來進行式分別:
Similarly the difference between past/future continuous tense and past/future perfect continuous tense are the same.
2012-05-04 9:48 pm
I have been doing it now.
這句不會是now的
have been verbing的意思是「由早前一些時間開始一直到現在仍進行中」,所以用的輔助詞會是
I have been doing it for a long time.
I have been doing it since last month.
I have been doing it all my life.
I have been doing it for a year.

I am doing it now.
這句有now跟沒有now意思上亦可以不同
I am doing it.如果是自我陳述意思是當你問時/我回答/說這話時我正在做(你問的事)了。
I am doing it now文法上意思是「正在做當中」,但如果是回答有人問你,加了now意思是「我現在才開始做」。

2012-05-04 14:17:18 補充:
回應001的幽默

對女性來說
現在進行式I am doing it.意思是享受 - 例如I am dating "him"(我有一個靚仔男友)
完成進行式I have been doing it.意思是怨言/盼望有更好的 - 例如I have been dating "him"(跟友人說我有一個無奈男友).

對男性來說
現在進行式I am doing it.意思是興奮 - 例如I am loving you(我無時無刻愛著你啊)
完成進行式I have been doing it.意思是己經習以為常的 - 例如I have been loving you.(我一直都愛你你還有甚麼懷疑呢)
2012-05-04 5:15 pm
通常present perfect continuous tense 是用於表達還在努力經營中、未停過努力、很專注從事着某樁事兒的意思,很多時是從某一個已經過去了的記憶中的一個時刻談起這個努力中的事兒,所以用 'since' 或者 'for a period of time' 都很適當。看看寫成這樣如何:I have been doing it since childhood. 或者,I have been doing it for more than twenty years. 至於present continuous tense,說明正在參與、正是現職的意思、是進行中、未了、未停止的階段,又看看以下的句子:I am now doing it. 或者寫成說成:I am doing it now. 都很正確。如果想再強調一點,可以這樣表達:Now, I am doing it.但是,其實真正面對面溝通,說:I am doing it. 都已很清楚交待得到啦!所以用辭遣字是要配合場景,配合說話者和讀者或溝通雙方的了解程度,活用不同時態(tense),來組成表達你自己的句子或文章的。
2012-05-04 9:55 am
對女性來說
進行式有點興奮,
完成進行式卻又帶點空虛。

對男性來說
進行式有點疲累,
完成進行式卻又帶點心虛。


收錄日期: 2021-04-11 19:00:24
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20120504000051KK00050

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份