Lewis acids & bases

2012-05-02 4:49 am
1.Which statements below is/are true?

I.Hydrofluoric acid is a weaker Lewis acid than hydrochloric acid
II.Fluoride is a stronger Lewis base than chloride

Is statement 2 the correct explanation for that hydrofluoric acid is a weak acid in water?

2.Is there a chemical reaction taking place in the following cases?

I.Ammonia dissolve in water
II.Hydrochloric acid dissolve in water
III. Sodium hydroxide dissolve in water

3.Acutally what is the shape and natures of a hydrated hydroxide ion?
Will it form covalent bonds with water molecules like the hydrated hydrogen ions case forming coordinate bonds with lone pair of water to yield hydronium ions?
更新1:

中文的化學詞彙不太看的懂= =" 請用英文回答...

更新2:

Thank you very much for the translation!!! However, I can't hardly understand the affect of anions size on their stability. Actually what do you mean by a more even electron distribution? Also, what is the electron density? I think that should be sth aboutl those electron orbitals, right?

更新3:

Another question is that for the ammonia case, what makes ammonia a base? Is that the energy released by the formation of the new N-H bond is greater than that to destroy a O-H bond in water? I also wonder whether the reaction is exothermic or endothermic as water is quite a weak Lewis base.

更新4:

Umm....silly grammar mistake I can't hardly understand->I can hardly understand

更新5:

但為什麼反應一會進行?因為N的en也不弱?但相比下O的較強,所以解離常數很低?

回答 (2)

2012-05-04 7:52 am
✔ 最佳答案
1)路易斯酸 是接收孤電子對
路易斯鹼 是提供孤電子對
考慮酸平衡
HA+H2O-->H3O+ + A- HA是酸
F- 體積比Cl-細,Cl-能更有效分散負電荷(較穩定),使平衡位置在右方,酸性較高
Cl-較F-穩定代表HCl較HF不穩定 (平衡相對性)
所以可理解HCl較易接收接收孤電子,較強路易斯酸
所以I岩
同樣也可理解F-較易提供孤電子對,所以F-是較強路易斯鹼
F-是較強路易斯鹼,F2也是較強路易斯鹼
所以2都岩
F2是較強路易斯鹼,代表其離子也是較強路易斯鹼,代表HF是較弱路易斯酸所以statement 2 is the correct explanation for that hydrofluoric acid is a weak acid in water2)化學反應定義是有新物質生成
I.Ammonia dissolve in water 有
NH3溶水 NH3(g)-->NH3(aq)
NH3和水發生化學反應
NH3+H2O-->NH4+ + OH-
生成新物質NH4+ OH-II.Hydrochloric acid dissolve in water 有
HCl溶水 HCl(g)-->HCl(aq)
HCl和水發生化學反應
HCl+H2O-->H3O+ + Cl-
生成新物質 H3O+ Cl-III. Sodium hydroxide dissolve in water 沒有
NaOH溶水
NaOH(s)-->Na+(aq)+OH-(aq)
它和水沒有反應3)不會,h+ 會形成h3o+,是因為h+體積太小,和水結合的水合能很高
結合形式是h2o的孤電子對和h+的低能量空軌態形成配位共價鍵
oh-不會形成,因為體積大,h沒有能量空軌態,
而水的h也沒有能量空軌態

2012-05-14 18:28:28 補充:
體積大,軌態(orbital)也越大,自然容納兩粒孤電子的空間較大,電子密度(charge density)也越小,電子密度可理解成電子在軌態的密度,越高,孤電子越容易提供,越低,電子越難提供

事實上,鍵能(bond energy)同酸鹼離解度,沒有直接關係,因為鍵能主要是影響活化能(Ea),而主要影響因素,是離子的穩定性,考慮以下平衡

2012-05-14 18:28:32 補充:
NH3+H2O-->NH4+ + OH-
NH3+H2O--->NH2- + H3O+
OH-比NH2-穩定得多,所以反應二基本下會進行,可假設NH3只作鹼(BASE)就可
O en > N en ,抓住孤電子能力大,所以較穩定
這不用體積解釋,是因為同周期體積變化小,只考慮En就可
而同族就用體積解釋,因為由上至上,體積變化很大,這影響遠遠大於En

估計NH3+H2O-->NH4+ + OH-
是吸熱反應,因為離解常數低 Kb=1.8x10^-5

2012-05-14 18:33:13 補充:
OH-比NH2-穩定得多,所以反應二基本不會進行,可假設NH3只作鹼(BASE)就可
O en > N en ,抓住孤電子能力大,所以較穩定

2012-05-14 18:33:52 補充:
這不用體積解釋,是因為同周期體積變化小,只考慮En就可
而同族就用體積解釋,因為由上至下,體積變化很大,這影響遠遠大於En

2012-05-14 23:27:39 補充:
離解常數是由能量決定的
在很多平衡反應中,反應物也有足夠能量克服Ea,進行正向反應
所以在這情況下比較離子穩定性,就可

而不用考慮反應物的en,這是動力學(速率)的因素
參考: my
2012-05-13 1:55 am
The following is ONLY the TRANSLATED piece of answer from 小云
I’m not sure about its correctness!
Things in [ ] are my opinion/supplement

Here you are:

1) Lewis acid accepts lone pair of electrons
Lewis base donates lone pair of electrons

2012-05-12 17:55:59 補充:
Concerning the dynamic equilibrium of acid HA
HA + H2O <----> H3O+ + A-

As F- ion is smaller than Cl- in size,
Cl- can have a more even distribution of negative charge [which is from electrons]

2012-05-12 17:56:23 補充:
This make Cl- more stable [than F-],
So, the equilibrium position lies [more] on the right [for “HCl + H2O <----> H3O+ + Cl-” than “HF + H2O <----> H3O+ + F-”]

2012-05-12 17:56:35 補充:
[Thus, there will be more H3O+ in the equilibrium of hydrochloric acid than that of hydrofluoric acid]
[Such that hydrochloric acid is] more acidic [than hydrofluoric acid]

2012-05-12 17:57:09 補充:
Cl- is more stable than F-
means that HCl is less stable than HF [“平衡相對性”, I don’t know what is it = =]
Which can be understood as HCl accepts electrons better and thus is a stronger Lewis acid

So, statement I is correct

2012-05-12 17:58:06 補充:
{In the same sense,
F- donates lone pair of electrons [easier than Cl-]
So, F- is a stronger Lewis base [than Cl-]
F- is a strong Lewis base
And F2 is also a strong Lewis base
So, 2 is correct

2012-05-12 17:58:16 補充:
F2 is also a strong Lewis base means that its ions are also strong Lewis base,
Thus, it means that HF is a weak Lewis acid
So, statement 2 is the correct explanation for that hydrofluoric acid is a weak acid in water.}

[Things in{} are quite confusing, not really know what they means]

2012-05-12 17:58:27 補充:
2)
Definition of chemical reaction is that there are new substance(s) formed
I. Ammonia dissolve in water
New substance formed
NH3 dissolve in water: NH3(g)-->NH3(aq)
NH3 then react with water: NH3+H2O-->NH4+ + OH-
New substances formed : NH4+ and OH-

2012-05-12 17:58:56 補充:
II. Hydrochloric acid dissolve in water
New substance formed
HCl dissolve in water: HCl(g)-->HCl(aq)
HCl then react with water: HCl+H2O-->H3O+ + Cl-
New substances formed : H3O+ and Cl-

2012-05-12 17:59:02 補充:
III. Sodium hydroxide dissolve in water
No new substances formed
NaOH dissolve in water: NaOH(s)-->Na+(aq)+OH-(aq)
It has no reaction with water

2012-05-12 17:59:23 補充:
3)
No [OH- won’t form covalent bonds with water as H+ does]
H+ forms H3O+ is because the size of H+ is too small that the hydration energy is very high
The way of combining [H+ and H2O] is:

2012-05-12 17:59:36 補充:
Lone pair of H2O forms dative covalent bond[=coordinate bond] with the low-energy empty orbital of H+
OH- won’t form [covalent bonds with water as H+ does]

2012-05-12 18:00:13 補充:
Because it is large, [and its] H [atom] have no [low-energy] empty orbital, neither do the H atom[s] of water.

[I don’t quite understand what’s it saying for Q3]


That's all, hope I can help you =]


收錄日期: 2021-04-18 14:13:48
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20120501000051KK00781

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份