wh問句時,is/are和do/does跪地求英文高手...

2012-02-07 6:39 am
都是prsent continuous tense 而且都係where 的問句:

Where do they living?

Where are you going for your holidays this year?

為何一句用do, 一句用are?

(兩句都是從著名grammar book 取得的例句.)


p.s
以參考其他地方明白

Are you hungry? 重點放於 adj.

Do you work for harrington's? 重點放於 v.
(雖然也不知這樣理解對不對)

可是加了wh words(where, who, when, etc.)大就變得好亂>口</

回答 (3)

2012-02-07 1:54 pm
✔ 最佳答案
Throw away your famous grammar book.

either
Where are they living ?
or
Where do they live ?

Where do they living ? is wrong.

2012-02-07 18:52:53 補充:
Are you hungry? 重點放於 adj. No, 無特別重點。
Do you work for harrington's? 重點放於 verb. No, 無特別重點。

2012-02-08 07:04:49 補充:
可是加了wh words(where, who, when, etc.)就變得好亂。
沒有什麼亂,問的東西不一樣。like

Where do you work ? 你在那裡上班
Whom are you working for ? 你現在的老板是誰
When do you work ? 你什麼時候落班
2012-02-11 3:15 am
wh問句 is/am/are 好似系被動句
do/does 就主動句
參考: 自己
2012-02-07 7:29 am
Check again with your teacher for your first sentence:

Where do they living? (wrong)
Compare above with: Where do you live? (see the difference?)

Either: Where do they live? (Correct) or
Where are they living? (correct).

2012-02-07 10:42:56 補充:
*將答案改變成一條問題*
(1) Interogative pronouns疑問代詞, e.g. Who, What, Where, Why, When因為他們有獨特的含義,不難構成各種 question。

(2) 其他的句子,當其中有is/are/was/were 或auxiliary verb助動詞 e.g. ought, have, must, need,你可以反轉這些助動詞形成一條問題。

(3) 一些 regular verbs正規動詞如沒有其它助動詞,那麼你可以使用“do”或“did”,來組成 question 的提問。

2012-02-07 11:10:45 補充:
回到 (1):
當然,在你使用疑問代詞,以組成一個問題的時候,例如 Where do they live?
“do” 字後不用加“ing”;

而在 "is” 或“are” 後,則要加“ing” ,如:
Where are they living?


收錄日期: 2021-04-16 13:59:36
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20120206000051KK00940

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份