f4 phy

2012-01-28 10:36 am
1.If a lift is stationary,weight = normal force,scale reading R = weight
If the lift moves downwards,weight>normal force,
The scale reading decreases.
But the normal force remains unchanged although the weight increases.
Why does the reading decrease?
What does the balance measure?Weight or normal force?

2.Newton's third law applies to two objects interacting each other.
Why it doesn't apply to one object by itself?


圖片參考:http://imgcld.yimg.com/8/n/HA04937267/o/701201280008713873431801.jpg


Consider Figure 1.Why forces in Figure 1 don't form an action-and-reaction pair?They are equal in magnitude and different in direction.
更新1:

When the lift moves downwards,force acts on the balance increases,so the normal reaction force acts on you will increase.Then why the reading will decrease?

回答 (1)

2012-01-28 8:36 pm
✔ 最佳答案
1.Q: What does the balance measure?Weight or normal force?

A: The balance measures the force that exerts on it. Th normal force R is the reaction force given by the balance. Because action and reaction forces are equal in magnitude, the reading on the balance gives the magnitude of the normal force R.

Q: But the normal force remains unchanged although the weight increases.
Why does the reading decrease?

A; No, the weight doesn't change. The weight is the pull of gravity on the man, which would not change due to motion/acceleraton. The reading on the balance changes because of a change of normal force R.

2. Both diagrams in fact show forces in action-reaction pairs.

Q:Why it doesn't apply to one object by itself?
A: An object could only acts as a "force provider" or a "force receiver". It cannot be both, as a force could only act on another object.



2012-01-28 23:38:02 補充:
Your suppl question:
When the lift moves downward, you are now falling slower relative to the lift than when the lift is at rest. Hence, the force exerted onto the balance decreases (just imagine if the lift moves downward at your falling speed, there would not be any force exerts on the balance).

2012-01-28 23:40:49 補充:
(cont'd)... Thus, the normal reaction force becomes reduced. On the other hand, if the lift moves upward, it has to push your body up. The force exerted on the balance increases, this causes the normal force to increase.


收錄日期: 2021-04-20 12:05:00
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20120128000051KK00087

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份