UK大學比較(20點)

2012-01-22 3:43 am
NEWCASTLE同LIVERPOOL比較,係在港名氣同實力方面邊間幾D,定差唔多?

IF SIMPLY FOR RANKINGS, BOTH WORLD RANKING AND LOCAL RANKING,ALSO FOR MY SUBJECT, SEEMS NEWCASTLE IS BETTER

BUT I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW MORE ABOUT THINGS LIKE REPUTATION AMONG HK PPL/EMPLOYERS, WHICH COULD NOT BE REFLECTED BY RANKING OR DATA

I'VE VISITED 某大公司'S WEBSITE, IT HAS HIRED NEWCASTLE'S GRADUATE, SO I THINK IT'S REPUTATION IS FINE, BUT I'VE ALSO HEARD ABT THAT LIVERPOOL IS 好出名,MORE PPL KNOW LIVERPOOL RATHER THAN NEWCASTLE, OR THE REPUTATION BETWEEN THEM IS MORE OR LESS THE SAME?

FOR ME, I LOVE NEWCASTLE'S PROGRAM MORE
但我實在聽過太多唔同講法,所以想攪清楚
1. 有人話兩間唔差太多,NEWCASTLE整體實力比較好 (但都要睇個別科目而定)
2. 亦有人話LIVERPOOL出名D,多人知D,但名大過實力,其實並唔係真係咁勁
而EMPLOYERS就覺得兩間都OK

SO, I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW, IS NEWCASTLE'S REPUTATION IN HK BETTER/ SIMILAR TO LIVERPOOL,因為我果科而言NEWCASTLE好D,亦聽人講話係出名,所以只要名氣方面唔差LIVERPOOL太多我都唔想放棄佢

COULD ANY EXPERIENCED PPL HELP? THX!

回答 (1)

2012-01-22 4:12 am
✔ 最佳答案
halo, 我係英國讀緊書, 希望幫到你丫=]

唔答你既問題住, 先講一講呢2間大學, 好多hk 識呢2間大學, 係因為佢地果邊既足球隊關係, 所以, 好多時d人都係聽得liverpool 既球隊多, 所以變左佢既出名度高好多, 但係對於一d 大公司黎講, 呢2間其實係差唔多, 唔係似話oxford 同liverpool咁, 一聽就知邊間好d咁. 希望你明白我既意思. 而公司方面, 佢有newcastle 既畢業生入去做, 唔一定係只會收呢間學生, 因為, 收人唔係只係睇咩學校出黎, 仲要睇佢既成績, 佢既cv, 佢既interview, 佢既assessment centre 既成績等等, 所以唔可以單係睇個profile 就話公司對newcastle 好好, 因為有一d 再差d 既學校, 大學interview 你, 如果你個人係夠勁夠醒既話, 都可以揮低newcastle呀, london uni 等等的. 而家答番你既問題:

1. 有人話兩間唔差太多,NEWCASTLE整體實力比較好 (但都要睇個別科目而定)

>> 一黎要睇係咩科, 一黎要睇係咩學校, 但係overall 黎講, 其實2間都係差唔多既.

2. 亦有人話LIVERPOOL出名D,多人知D,但名大過實力,其實並唔係真係咁勁
而EMPLOYERS就覺得兩間都Ok

>> 如果employers 有得揀, 佢地會先screen through 你係咩大學既, 如果係oxbridge, london uni 既話, 會更好, 之後會再screen 下睇下有冇一d 成績好勁而且你睇緊既只係一間公司而已, 唔代表全部既公司, 有一d 公司, 可以只會睇下係大學同成績而決定俾唔俾入場券你去interview 既. 好似某間公司為例, 如果你係讀oxbridge 或IC, 你可以跳過第一個step, 直接去到第2 round, 所以好明顯, 都有一公司係比較prefer 一d 再好既學校既學生.

最後, 以你呢個情況, 2間大學差唔多, 如果佢地既offer 係唔一樣既話, 你大可以放一個做firm, 一個做insurance, 咁就冇問題了, 如果佢地offer 係一樣, 你真係要揀既話, 我會覺得, 因為佢地都係差唔多, 所以你可以睇下邊個course 啱你, 邊一個地方你會想係果度stay 3年, 同埋邊一個地方係屋企既$$ 可以afford 到既.

希望幫到你丫, 有d咩可以再email我的=]

2012-01-22 05:29:37 補充:
1) liverpool 多人聽過既都係因為有足球隊, 但唔代表話球隊勁等於大學勁, 如果公司係咁睇既話, 咁我諗, 佢想要親既都會係oxbridge 學生, 冇咁好既大學睇都唔會睇了, 所以2者係唔可以一齊講的.

2)而如果你係鍾意newcastle 多一d 既話, 咁就newcastle 丫..因為入一間你唔鍾意既大學, 辛苦果個係你自己.

2012-01-22 05:32:29 補充:
3) 我會睇course 同reputation, 俾一個例子你, imperial 出名讀science, 但係佢既chemistry排名只有第8, 如果你想讀呢一科, 你會唔會因為佢係第8而唔揀佢? 同一個道理, overall reputation 好緊要, 而個course 你啱唔啱亦好緊要, ranking 年年都唔同, 最緊要既係student stat. 有幾好, 有一d大學, 所有野都好好, 係學生覺得唔好, 你就會知道, 果間大學應該ok 大壓力, 亦有一d 所有野都係好好, 但出到黎, 就係搵唔到野做, 你應該要逐個pt 睇, 而唔係睇overall

2012-01-22 09:29:58 補充:
1. 只可以話佢地好多時2間都係一齊被比較, 可算係差唔多.
2. 如果可以揀, 我會揀bristol, york, bath 等, 最後冇choice 先會揀newcastle
3. 算中等. 唔係係最top 或near top.

2012-01-23 03:34:45 補充:
4. 同leicester 差不多的

2012-01-23 12:10:26 補充:
冇話樣點樣樣仔細分, 既然你都決定要去newcastle, 咁其實都冇咩其他因素可以令到你改變的了.
參考: 多年uk留學exp :]


收錄日期: 2021-04-13 18:29:47
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20120121000051KK00573

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份