1 maths Q (What's wrong?)

2012-01-15 5:59 am
x/[(x+1)²(x-1)]=x/[(x+1)(x²-1)]Let x/[(x+1)(x²-1)]=A/(x+1)+(Bx+C)/(x²-1)__________________x=A(x²-1)+(Bx+C)(x+1)__________________x=Ax²-A+Bx²+Cx+Bx+C__________________x=(A+B)x²+(B+C)x+(C-A)By comparing thecoefficient of x.A+B=0 ---(1)B+C=1 ---(2)C-A=0 ---(3)(1)+(3),B+C=0 ---(4)Sub. (2) into (4), 1=0 1=0 ???!!!WHAT’S WRONG???

回答 (3)

2012-01-15 7:08 pm
✔ 最佳答案
Interesting, the point is the LCM of the denominator of the RHS of your 'Let' equation is (x²-1), not (x-1)(x+1)²,
which is differ from LHS.
So, you are using a wrong method.

(Instead, try the following)
Let x/[(x+1)(x²-1)]=(Bx+C)/(x²-1)+(Dx+E)/(x+1)²__________________x=(Bx+C)(x+1)+(Dx+E)(x-1)__________________x=(B+D)x²+(-B+C+D+E)x+(-Cx+E)By comparing the coefficientsB+D=0 --------(1)-B+C+D+E=1 ---(2)-C+E=0 -------(3)

So, D=-B, E=C, and 2B+2C=1
Suppose B=0, then C=1/2, D=0, E=1/2
x/[(x+1)(x²-1)]=(1/2)/(x²-1)+(1/2)/(x+1)²

Suppose C=0, then B=1/2, D=-1/2, E=0
x/[(x+1)(x²-1)]=(x/2)/(x²-1)-(x/2)/(x+1)²

Hope this can help you. (though it is not the best method)

2012-01-15 16:50:34 補充:
數無盡 學無涯 : But why can't it work

Ans : the denominator is wrong, so it can't work. for example
13/24 = A/4 + B/6
you can't find any integers that suitable for A and B and the LCM of 4 and 6 is not 24.
2012-01-15 7:48 pm
Because the sixth line is not identity . So you cannot compare coefficient .
2012-01-15 6:46 am
Notice that x^2 - 1 can be factored as (x - 1)(x + 1) and so it cannot be used in partial fraction directly.

In fact, x/[(x+1)(x²-1)]=A/(x+1)+(Bx+C)/(x²-1)

x/[(x+1)(x²-1)]=[A(x-1)+(Bx+C)]/(x²-1)

Hope it help



收錄日期: 2021-04-13 18:28:34
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20120114000051KK00912

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份