高手來看下這幾句句型哪裡有錯感謝:))

2011-11-25 10:08 pm
Q1.
a.If at the time I had taken your proposal, then I should have been happier.b.He will come if now you invite him.請問這兩題目...
我把 at the time 跟 now 放置這樣為什麼錯誤呢??? 不合語法? 沒逗號? or 不習慣這樣放?

Q2.
同q1 a.
為什麼主句那個should要換成would比較好@@??
這個我就想不出什麼原因 會的請告訴我大概為什麼
AND..最好能附上一些例子 哪種語氣用SHOULD哪種用WOULD比較好~.~''??

Q3.
最後這個問題其實是關於反身代詞 這個也是常常不理解的用法(會附上解釋)
先寫出例子 a.I saw the woman herself yesterday.
這題書本的例子...我看見她本人 只是我後面多放了時間副詞yesterdayb.I saw the man myself yesterday.
這題一樣書本例子...我自己看到這個人 同樣後置時間副詞
c.I, myself, came here yesterday.
d.I came here myself yesterday.
這兩題目不是例子只是
我似乎在看外國電影字幕上有看過這種用法故寫下=====================================================================================以上Q1-Q3
問過外國人說不太正確 但是在下我太笨拙 看不出來哪裡不正確?
因為看起來文法邏輯都正確阿~.~""
會的老師神人達人請幫看下 是我寫錯還是沒錯誤只是 外國人比較沒習慣這樣講@@?
更新1:

不會的請勿亂回答 感謝:)

更新2:

TO DaSaGwa I came here myself yesterday. I came here yesterday myself. Are they the same meaning?

回答 (3)

2011-11-25 11:25 pm
✔ 最佳答案
Q1:
The positions of "at the time" and "now" are correct. The position you have placed is to EMPHASIZE, so you place it at the beginning of the sentence.
You can also place them at the end of that clause that they belong to.

Q2
"should" is stronger than "would", since according to the meaning of "If at the time I had taken your proposal", it doesn't call for using "should". However, if you really think it is a BIG deal, yes, you can still use "should". I am sure grammar oriental people will insist to use "would", because it is what "if" clause will use. However, in my opinion, I think depending upon how serious you with the "if" clause, you can choose to use "should" or "would", but you cannot use "shall" or "will".

Q3
a.I saw the woman herself yesterday.
這題書本的例子...我看見她本人 只是我後面多放了時間副詞yesterday b.I saw the man myself yesterday.
這題一樣書本例子...我自己看到這個人 同樣後置時間副詞The above sentences and your Chinese translation are perfectly correct. There is NO need to add "yesterday" at the end of the sentence unless you really want to specifiy when it happened. English does have tense to tell people when it happens. In Chinese, we need to add "adverb" like "today", "yesterday", "tomorrow", " to tell people when it actually happens.

c.I, myself, came here yesterday.
d.I came here myself yesterday.

The difference between "c" and "d" is in "c", you REALLY want to bring people to the attention that it is "I" and "myself" only came here. Therefore, if you compare the following sentences:

I, myself, came here yesterday.
I came here myself yesterday.
I came here yesterday.

They all carry somewhat the same meaning, but the emphasis of "I" reduced from the first to the last.



2011-11-25 18:19:15 補充:
master Louis!, thank you for your more detail explanation

2011-11-25 18:20:12 補充:
"myself" is pronoun (reflective), therefore, it is better to place close to subject like the first sentence in your supplemental question

2011-11-25 18:21:04 補充:
However, in conversational situation, people might place it in the end of the sentence, because they want to RE-emphasize.

2011-11-25 18:23:49 補充:
since it is not formal usage, therefore, I still suggest you to place it as close to the subject as possible. After all, you try to learn the right English.

2011-11-25 18:25:21 補充:
As I always tell people, you shall learn the English the right way first, then you can use it in a dynamic way that may not follow the grammatical rules procisely.
參考: self
2011-11-26 6:53 am
如果(1a)要用"should"一詞,前半句的重點將放在"had"而非"if"上,因此整個句型已不再是假設句句型。

IF you have been there, then you WOULD recognise the place straight away.
“如果”(假設)你去過那裡,那麼你“會”一眼就認出那地方。

If you HAVE been there, then you SHOULD recognise the place straight away.
如果你(真的)“去過”那裡,那麼你“應該”一眼就認出那地方。

2011-11-25 23:05:38 補充:
我看見她本人 - I saw her in person.
我看見她本人自己親自畫畫 - I saw her drew that herself.

我昨天自己一個人來 - I came here by myself yesterday.
我昨天本人親自來 - I came here myself yesterday.
2011-11-26 12:27 am
should和would的語意不同。用should表示和[責任]有關,用would表示和[可能性]有關。比較:He thought that I should do it.(他認為我應該做)和He thought that I would do it.(他認為我可能會做)。


收錄日期: 2021-04-24 22:53:01
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20111125000016KK02897

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份