Which用法((急

2011-11-23 5:34 am
Some chemicals _ for makeup were deadly to our body.
(A)using
(B)which used
(C)used
(D)to use
答案是C 請問為什麼B不能呢??
更新1:

那請問能用 are used 嗎?

更新2:

若是選項有 are used 可以選嗎?

回答 (4)

2011-11-23 5:55 am
✔ 最佳答案
因為該句是從下面這句演變來的:Some chemicals which are used for makeup were deadly to our body.
有些「被」用來做成化粧品的化學物,很傷害我們的身體。 在關代的句型中,which + be動詞,常可被省略,就成為:
Some chemicals used for makeup were deadly to our body.(意思不變)
所以,其它三個答案,均不適用。




2011-11-23 13:30:24 補充:
你若要用 “are used” ,那麼整句就要改寫成:
Some chemicals are used for makeup, and they are deadly to our body. (現在式:不變的真理、事實;其實以原句的意思用現在式會更合宜)。
Some chemicals were used for makeup, and they were deadly to our body. (過去式:發生在過去某時間點;而現在可能就不得而知是否還有這種狀況)。
they指“Some chemicals”。

2011-11-23 14:01:09 補充:
你若要用 “are used” ,那麼整句就要改寫成:
Some chemicals are used for makeup, and they are deadly to our body. (現在式:不變的真理、事實;其實以原句的意思用現在式會更合宜)。
Some chemicals were used for makeup, and they were deadly to our body. (過去式:發生在過去某時間點;而現在可能就不得而知是否還有這種狀況)。
they指“Some chemicals”。
2011-11-23 5:19 pm
呆子+1

既然後面 were deadly ... 是過去式,
前面應該也是用過去式 some chemicals (which were) used ...
2011-11-23 8:22 am
Some chemicals which were used for makeup were deadly to our body.-----
2011-11-23 6:25 am
Pony +1
cannot be any better


收錄日期: 2021-04-24 22:52:44
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20111122000015KK06895

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份