jimmy rollins vs shane victorino?

When healthy, Jimmy Rollins is far better than Victorino!

J Roll. Has more RBI's and homeruns.

Jimmy Rollins

shane victorino of course.

Shane Victorino.

It's Shane Victorino - no question.

Victorino has a much higher average, OBP, and slugging percentage, along with more home runs. I find it hard to believe that anyone who watches the Phillies would think Rollins is better.

Victonio because he gets hurt less and is younger but overall their numbers are very similar and both are key players for the phillies all in all I'm glad we have both lol

Jimmy is more of the leader of the two but right now I would say that Shane is the better player. he is been better the past few years. He also is younger than jimmy so he has more juice left in him

Both players are specialists who play a key position and both hold 3 Gold Gloves. And both players, although currently not the best in the league, both rank fairly highly,

Rollins was better 3 years ago, but Shane is currently an important part of the team. That makes them about equal across the board. Both have equal value to the club.