wh- question 的問題

2011-09-11 12:46 am
想問以下邊一句是正確的:
1. I would like to ask when could we find the dog?
2. I would like to ask when we could find the dog?
3. Do you know when could we find the dog?
4. Do you know when we could find the dog?

回答 (4)

2011-09-11 8:40 am
✔ 最佳答案
是2,4文化正確

首先我們要談談直接問句(direct question)與間接問句(indirect question)
所謂直接問句是我們一般的問句,問句非在另一句子中,這種句子會用倒裝法(inversion),即助動詞,情態動詞等,會在主詞前,如:

Who are you?
Do you know my uncle?

但間接問句即問句是附屬於另一主句,間接問句與其它句子一樣,不用倒裝,即主詞在助動詞,動詞,情態動詞前,如:

I don't know who he is.
Tell me what you want.
Do you know who wants the car?

就因為這樣,所以正確答案是2,4

希望幫到你!
2011-09-13 5:05 am
1. I would like to ask when could we find the dog? X
I would like to know when we could find the dog. = indirect question - this is better than no.2

2. I would like to ask when we could find the dog. OK but with full stop not question mark.

3. Do you know when could we find the dog? X
4. Do you know when we could find the dog? correct - nothing needs to be changed.

Only no. 4 is correct as no change is required at all.
2011-09-12 11:06 pm
2,4是文法結構正確的寫法,不過當中的could則有點怪,跟句子所表達意思有點格格不入的矛盾。

用when...find the dog表示你是想問何時才能找到那隻狗,但could即是can(能不能)的意思,所以不是在問甚麼時間而是暗示如何才能找得到那隻狗。所以這個助動詞也要跟問的問題相配才可以的。

即是我重寫這問題

I would like to ask when we will find the dog.
Do you know when we will find the dog.

2011-09-11 5:01 am
Sentence 1 and 3 are both grammatically correct.
But, I think sentence 3 is better.
參考: I, Myself


收錄日期: 2021-04-11 18:44:59
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20110910000051KK00566

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份