點解外傭拿working visa 可以取居留權,咁所謂住滿

2011-08-20 6:59 pm

如題
1.點解外傭拿working visa 可以取居留權,即係香港人移民到外國都可以用同樣方式取得一級居留?

2.咁所謂住滿7年的非香港居民可有居留權,是否只應限制於某情況?

3.而呢種情況下取得居留權的非香港居民,由於不是原居民或透過條件門檻申請,那福利是否應限制於某情況?

4.如果居留權是有分級別,而會祗觸人權法,即如美國及其他國家移民法都祗觸人權法了,那是否因為有特別條文可凌駕此例??

回答 (2)

2011-08-21 10:11 am
✔ 最佳答案
1. No one ever said foreigner workers can get residency at all. The case is simply arguing the Basic Law gives them the right. But no one knows until the trial. Beside, foreign workers are subject to immigration control. So it is a doubt that how they can meet the "ordinary residing" requirement.

By the way, residency in other places does not work like this.

2. No one ever said that.

3. No.

4. They are in different system. Simply saying, other places have better systems in handling these issues.
2011-09-01 6:03 am
雖然香港是自由之都,自由發言是人權賦於我們的自由。但此問題的惟一以中文作答的解答者根本沒有解答問題,純粹「抽水」和「借吔椅」大發偉論。所以香港的大、中與小學學生都被垢病答非所問,真悲哀!

收錄日期: 2021-04-27 15:37:08
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20110820000051KK00280

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份