英文難題:找尋英文高手=]

在乎於句中的''you''是否可能是個學生
如果''you''是個學生,但有機會變成非學生或根本''you''不是個學生的話
grammar上是對的
如果''you''是個學生,不可能不是學生的話,
就該改成'If you were not a student'

發問者: If you ( 您 ) are not a student, you ( 您 ) never say that the others/the other people are students. If you ( 您們 ) are not students, you ( 您們 ) never say that the others/the other people are students.

You are not is 是文法上的大錯, 因一般只應寫：
I am not....
You are not....
We are not....
They are not....
She is not....
He is not.....
It is not.....

'Are'同埋'is'都係動詞'be'，
只不過係連接唔同性質嘅主語。
呢度嘅其中一個問題係，
第一個子句有兩個主動詞。

合符文法嘅講法係：
'If you are/were not a student'

多謝你的回答 我想要問問you are not is的用法及原因? 到底它是否對的?thx=]