AL chem: bacisity of Fe(OH)2

2011-04-10 1:22 am
2005 al chem 問:
why Fe(OH)2 (s) is stronger base than Fe(OH)3 (s)


marking :
since Fe3+ has a higher charge density than Fe3+ than Fe 2+,it will bind to the O atom in OH- more strongly than Fe2+(1M)
in Fe(OH)3 the O-H bond is highly polarised, it is not easy for Fe(OH)3 to donate its lone electron pairs on O to acids.
呢句點解?

回答 (2)

2011-04-10 7:40 pm
✔ 最佳答案
The charge of Fe3+ is larger than that of Fe2+ (obviously). Lone pair of electrons on the O atom ( in OH-) is attracted more tightly to the Fe3+. H+ from acid can easier take away the OH- from a 2+ charge ion than a 3+ charge ion.

illustrated guide:

H+ ------------(OH-)-------(Fe2+)
easier to remove OH-

H+ ----------------(OH-)---(Fe3+)
more difficult to remove OH-

2011-04-10 12:00:17 補充:
OH- in Fe3+ is more polarized than the OH- in Fe2+. It is different so you should also mention that.
2011-04-12 2:17 am
plastic:
i think the argument follows your discussion, while the result is not exactly the same.

What is the meaning of the "base" in the question?

base can dissociate to give hydroxide ion; this's definition of Arrhenius base.
yet, in this case it should follow Bronsted base / Lewis base, which is proton-acceptor / electron pair donor. the argument should follow Lewis base for easier discussion.

yes, Fe(III) has higher charge density, which attracts the electrons on O-atom more strongly. this reduces the electron density (and thus lone pair availability) on O-atom in hydroxo-ligand.
proton is less readily attracted by the lone pair, thus the basicity of Fe(III) is weaker.


what plastic suggests also make sense. but notice that the valency on Fe-center has to be fulfilled anyway, either by hydroxo-ligand (:OH) or aqua-ligand (:OH2).
it's not very likely for the complex to break the Fe-O bond and release hydroxide ion (OH-).
           H             H
           |             |
H+ 。。。。。。 :O-Fe  <==>  H-O-Fe
                         +

i think where strong-polarization occurs is Fe-O bond, not the O-H bond.


收錄日期: 2021-04-20 00:32:48
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20110409000051KK00794

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份