新手打debate， 缺經驗。我班好快會有英文辯論，辯題幾搞笑，叫We should try to prevent species from becoming extinct. 我做正方，唸落就真係企起道德高地~
各位人兄，幫手唸下反方會有咩論點? 我地又可以點打?請高人指點指點，等我地可以準備得好d。謝謝。
身為正方又可以以咩特別ge approach 去打? 可以俾人高d印象分?
prefer 英文回答，當然..中文亦可!
新手打英文辯論，缺經驗，幫手唸下對手會有咩論點，急20分
2011-01-31 12:44 am
回答 (3)
2011-02-01 12:42 am
正方的重點：
balance of the eco system - e.g. consequence of food chain/predator-prey imbalance, diversity promotes evolutionary development, economic impact for farming/fishing/plantation/agriculture/food processing/living, stewardship of being the supreme being on Earth, human activity distruption of the natural survial, etc.
事實上不是道德高地，只是我們過去把人類活動的影響(例如工業生產,追求多元食物而過度捕獵等)計進地球的生態鍊中。主要的論點可以仍以人類求生存的角度去比較物種消失去人類生活的影響，最好以達致持續維生，延續世代得享今天同樣或至更好的生活質素為主旨。不要採取極端主義的方式說成自我滅絕的類比或最終結果，這樣反而令反方易於以純科學的引證這種極端情況是不會出現的。
反方可能會：
natural selection-survival of the fittest(物競天擇-適者生存), natual balance, insufficient research to justify the real cause of extinction cases to prevent, etc.
反方也不易說明為何生物絕種不重要，最多只能按一些「理論」和未能證實物種消失(絕種)對世界的影響未至於全球性。
balance of the eco system - e.g. consequence of food chain/predator-prey imbalance, diversity promotes evolutionary development, economic impact for farming/fishing/plantation/agriculture/food processing/living, stewardship of being the supreme being on Earth, human activity distruption of the natural survial, etc.
事實上不是道德高地，只是我們過去把人類活動的影響(例如工業生產,追求多元食物而過度捕獵等)計進地球的生態鍊中。主要的論點可以仍以人類求生存的角度去比較物種消失去人類生活的影響，最好以達致持續維生，延續世代得享今天同樣或至更好的生活質素為主旨。不要採取極端主義的方式說成自我滅絕的類比或最終結果，這樣反而令反方易於以純科學的引證這種極端情況是不會出現的。
反方可能會：
natural selection-survival of the fittest(物競天擇-適者生存), natual balance, insufficient research to justify the real cause of extinction cases to prevent, etc.
反方也不易說明為何生物絕種不重要，最多只能按一些「理論」和未能證實物種消失(絕種)對世界的影響未至於全球性。
2011-01-31 11:22 am
You are proposing the idea so its easier in this case, i think...
You can do some research on statistics. No. of animals are becoming extinct or have extinct. Then explain why its bad thing that the animals are becoming extinct. Leads to environmental issues because its their habitat, so if they have become extinct, what will happen? And you can talk about the animal food chain. The system will corrupt if certain species becomes extinct.
Just some basic ideas, hope it helps!
You can do some research on statistics. No. of animals are becoming extinct or have extinct. Then explain why its bad thing that the animals are becoming extinct. Leads to environmental issues because its their habitat, so if they have become extinct, what will happen? And you can talk about the animal food chain. The system will corrupt if certain species becomes extinct.
Just some basic ideas, hope it helps!
參考: my brain
2011-01-31 2:11 am
收錄日期: 2021-04-11 18:31:37
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20110130000051KK00770