Christians, can an all powerful, perfect being get tired and need to rest?

2010-11-14 9:46 pm
and be refreshed after resting?

Gen 2:2 And on the seventh day God ended his work which he had made; and he rested on the seventh day from all his work which he had made.

Gen 2:3 And God blessed the seventh day, and sanctified it: because that in it he had rested from all his work which God created and made.

Exd 20:11 For [in] six days the LORD made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that in them [is], and rested the seventh day: wherefore the LORD blessed the sabbath day, and hallowed it.

Exd 31:17 It [is] a sign between me and the children of Israel for ever: for [in] six days the LORD made heaven and earth, and on the seventh day he rested, and was refreshed.
更新1:

Those who are saying "rested" does not imply God was tired, how can one be "refreshed" if one had not been tired?

更新2:

@P.P.G., you say 'there is no mention of "refreshment"'. Did you not read the bible verses I posted? The very last word in the last verse is "refreshed".

更新3:

@Fred, since when is asking a question "hateful"?

更新4:

@ Jack, you tell me that we cannot understand God and then proceed to tell me you understand God. :)

更新5:

Regarding it being "hateful" to direct a question about the old testament to Christians and not to Jews, I must say I find this truly surprising. Surely, Christians are not now claiming that the old testament is not part of their religion? Is it Jews and not Christians who are often wanting the Ten Commandments in government buildings and public schools? Do Christian bible literalists not believe in Adam and Eve and the story of Creation? It never occured to me to direct this question to Jews for I have never encountered a Jewish person who takes the stories of the old testament literally, but I have encountered numerous Christians who do. I appreciate the few Christians and others on here who have actually attempted to answer my question. Thanks!

回答 (25)

2010-11-14 10:05 pm
✔ 最佳答案
The resting part means he just ceased from his work, it was finished. The refreshing part was God just looking over the creation, saying to himself, it is good. Remember what Genesis 1:2 says.

" And the earth was without form, and void; and darkness was upon the face of the deep."

Some of us believe that Genesis is not a creation account of the earth, but a restoration account of the earth after some cataclysmic event had occurred. Looking over your work in restoring the earth would indeed be refreshing to your spirit.
2010-11-14 9:48 pm
He chose to create the universe in six days and rest on the seventh to give us a pattern to follow in the Sabbath laws. God still expects us to rest and worship Him one day out of the week.
參考: 2 Thess 3:5
2010-11-14 9:49 pm
God never slumbers or sleeps. That's also in scripture. The answer to your question is no. God teaches by example. He set aside a day to rest as a pattern we frail humans need to follow.
2010-11-14 9:49 pm
NO. The Hebrew word for rest actually means that he simply stopped working. God never tires according to scripture.

Psa 121:4 Behold, he that keepeth Israel shall neither slumber nor sleep.
2010-11-14 9:48 pm
I do not believe he "needs" to rest; he chooses to rest. Big difference.
2010-11-14 9:49 pm
I don't mean to offend you but your question is glaring
biblical illiteracy.
2010-11-14 9:48 pm
Clearly, if it says so in the Bible.
2010-11-14 9:51 pm
Resting doesn't necessarily imply tiredness or need.
參考: Atheist
2010-11-14 9:54 pm
I guess He does as He pleases, after all He's God ya know

God Bless
2010-11-14 9:47 pm
that's a contradiction they are going to deny again.
2010-11-14 9:52 pm
Michelle, you may get better answers if you direct your Old Testament questions to Jews. Well, I see that you used to be a fundamentalist. Did you fall away because of this question? You say that you are filled with compassion but don't you remember that all goodness comes from God? If there was no God, only evil would exist in the world.

For me, God = Good, Devil = Evil. Can you deny that such forces exist and influence people's lives? Or are these inspirations generated from hormones pumping through your body?
2010-11-14 9:51 pm
Resting and Tired and not the same thing but usually go along with each other, the lord might have been resting and admiring creation, also its a bad translation as the original says, "god rested the seventh day" and there is no mention of "refreshment"
2010-11-14 9:47 pm
IT MEANS ADMIRING HIS WORK...
2010-11-14 11:06 pm
I am not a Christian and I do not propose to answer for the Christian viewpoint. I'm Jewish and Genesis is the first book of the Torah. I'm rather amazed to see a good answer about the Jewish religion's view of this coming from a non-Jew in the copy-paste of Aryeh Kaplan's words, but disturbed that it was attached to an unsubstantiated insult to the asker, therefore I cannot give it a thumb up for that reason.

To answer the question about Genesis and about God with regard to the Shabbat, here is another excellent piece from the perspective of Judaism. Rather than copy-paste it, I'll provide the links
http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/Judaism/shabbat1.html
http://www.aish.com/sh/t/e/Does_God_Get_Tired__The_Sabbath_Part_1.html

I read nothing in the question that is hateful or insulting. The fact that it addressed Christians only also puzzled me if it was speaking about Genesis, but considering that Christians consider their adaptation of Tanakh, their Old Testament, a huge portion of their Bible, if she was wishing to understand the Christian perspective on this, how else would she address a question that's been asked by Jews and others for centuries?
Please see and read the references below for more.

EDITED to note, since there appears to be a bit of confusion: Gensis is indeed the first book of the Torah, and of the Jewish Bible. However, Judaism has no "Old Testament". Judaism's Scriptures remain as they state within them, an eternal testament ( covenant ) Testament means covenant. Old Testament is the name given in the 3rd century by Tertullian to the Christian religion's adaptation/alteration of the Holy Scriptures of Judaism, the Tanakh ( an acronym for Torah = Teaching/law, Nevim= Prophets, Ketuvim=Writings)
The Christian Bible's Old Testament (it’s adaptation of Tanakh) reveals that in many places (not most, but many) there are significant translation differences rendering the meanings of the passages quite different. Not only are the books rearranged so that the books are not in the order of Torah, Prophets and Writings, but Kings, Ezra and Nehemiah are divided. Even though re-arranged, the Protestant Old Testament contains roughly the same books; the Vulgate has additional texts added to the canon that were originally written in Greek. The Greek Septuagint (meaning 70) was originally referring to the Torah portion only, and in fact, that is the only portion that was translated by 72 scribes whose translations matched. The rest of Tanakh was translated from the Hebrew to the Greek over the course of about 300 years and scholars cannot tell who or when exactly any of them were translated. Yet the common name of Septuagint is now generally applied to the whole Greek translation. By the beginning of the first century CE, there were many different versions of each text that appeared, some of them with less accurate Hebrew to Greek, and during this time, many other texts appeared being originally written IN Greek such as the books of the Maccabees. By the time of the beginnings of Christianity, some of these texts of Tanakh had become so changed through the Hellenization (introduction of Greek philosophical concepts through language) that they were no longer adherent to Torah precept. The ancient world was one in which the religion and customs of the ruling people were imposed upon the conquered..Jewish law always forbade such attempts to syncretize.
2010-11-14 9:56 pm
So you are saying that when you refresh your computer screen, its because it was tired...Lets keep simple definitions simple and stop being so hateful.
2010-11-14 9:53 pm
You can finish a job in the middle of the day, but you can look back and see the job has finally come to a finish and then be rested or pleased by what you have accomplished.
Maybe his days are billions of years long? So he had reason to stop and look back and see the many variety's of plant and animal life and how they worked together.
Does not mean he was actually tired.
2010-11-14 10:06 pm
You don't know much about refreshment and rest.

God can choose to rest. God can also experience emotion. God exists outside of time and space as well as within time and space. God was here when you wrote this question at the same "time" that He was creating the world.

People can cause God emotional pain. And you question how an emotional being might need refreshment?

Quit now while you are ahead. There is more to God than any can understand.

You don't read very well...or you come to false conclusions.

Re-read my statement. Partial understanding is not understanding. Just because I have a few pieces of the jig-saw puzzle does not mean that I have the whole picture.

I understand that my tone is "aggressive". I am intentionally challenging your statements and claiming them false.

Calm down. Learn and grow.
2010-11-14 9:54 pm
God gave man logic and reason, but He doesn't need them for Himself. God is an infinite being, our bodies are finite and need rest. Flesh and bones deteriorate and die. God does not.
參考: My own observations. and the Holy Christian Bible.
2010-11-14 9:53 pm
*Facepalm*

Study Judaism and learn what "rest" and "work" mean in the context of the Sabbath. It means refraining from creating and modifying; that's why Jews can't even pick a flower on the Sabbath. It has nothing to do with being tired.

I agree with Ra that OT questions should be directed toward Jews.

----------------------------

From Rabbi Aryeh Kaplan:

G-d did not rest because He was tired or overworked. Even creating a universe is not hard work for G-d. Our sages teach us that it involved less effort than to pronounce a single letter.

G-d rested in another sense. He rested when He stopped creating ---when He no longer interfered with His world. This gives us an insight into the Torah's definition of Sabbath rest.

We rest in a Sabbath sense when we no longer interfere with the world. In this way, we emulate G-d's rest on the Sabbath, when He stopped interfering with His world.

During the six days of Creation, G-d asserted His mastery over the universe by actively changing it. On the Sabbath, He "rested" by no longer asserting this mastery.

We emulate G-d by relinquishing our mastery over the world on the Sabbath.

We now have a new understanding of work that makes the entire concept of the Sabbath make sense.

More at http://www.ou.org/publications/kaplan/shabbat/rest.htm

----------------

>>@Fred, since when is asking a question "hateful"?<<

It is hateful because you aren't trying to gain a true understanding of the verses; you are trying to harass Christians. Why else would you be asking Christians about a Jewish text?

>>Regarding it being "hateful" to direct a question about the old testament to Christians and not to Jews, I must say I find this truly surprising...It never occured to me to direct this question to Jews for I have never encountered a Jewish person who takes the stories of the old testament literally, but I have encountered numerous Christians who do.<<

It sounds like you are admitting you know very well it was never meant to be taken in the sense of God getting "tired" and that you asked this question hoping to laugh at what you assumed would be silly answers by Christians.
2010-11-15 1:55 am
"God called the light 'DAY'. Therefore ,a day was 24 hours and not a billion years, as some have suggested. Work and rest have always been opposites. One does not ''rest" unless one is tired,and they would not be considered "refreshed" if they were not tired. Therefore, your question is valid, and this is indeed another of the (oh so many) contradictions in the ancient scribblings of those ignorant goat herders who have sought to enlighten people with their childish tales.
2010-11-14 9:52 pm
There are thousands of contradictions in the bible. I honestly have absolutely no idea why so many people miss it all.
People change jobs for "Jehovah", they change residences for "Jehovah", they choose spouses in the name of "Jehovah", they deny their ambitions and naturalities for "Jehovah", this has gone on for millenium, and the only people to point this out have been slandered and ignored.
2010-11-14 9:50 pm
You got a point. So my answer was "maybe".

Who cares, God the Father had His Son in charge as well as the Holy Spirit. If that ain't enough, there were lots of angels to do some minor stuffs.

Α†Ω™
2010-11-14 9:47 pm
ITS A METAPHOR .... GOD IS ALL POWERFUL & YOU ARE INTERPRETING THOSE PASSAGES WRONG...

repent to god for forgivenss..
2016-12-05 1:44 pm
The Bible is the certainty whilst it truly is an precise translation. basically simply by fact something sounds like a contradiction to you does no longer mean that it truly is. It basically ability which you do no longer are responsive to it. you in all hazard went to a internet site that lists Bible expenses out of context and by no ability study the Bible for your self. I disagree with Josh under me. genuine Christianity is according to faith AND reason. it is maximum genuine interior the doctrines of the Catholic Church. study the Catechism of the Catholic Church in case you opt to understand the Bible. yet I also have a feeling which you truly decide to proceed to be ignorant considering seems to be the way of the international right this moment.
2010-11-14 10:13 pm
It is not uncommon for some anthropomorphism to take place in Scripture.

God "rested" from that work because He was done; finished. A lawyer rests his case when he is done.

.


收錄日期: 2021-04-21 18:12:52
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20101114134603AAHGIlU

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份