精神分裂後殺人會否控告殺人罪?

2010-07-11 8:18 pm
如題,
精神分裂後殺人會否控告殺人罪?
如果唔會,
咁會告佢咩罪?

回答 (4)

2010-07-12 6:12 am
✔ 最佳答案
即使有足夠證據證明被告人殺人而觸犯刑法,例如侵害人身罪條例的第2條(即謀殺),被告人仍可提出免責辯護,而最常見的抗辯理由就係精神錯亂(即精神有病),即你所講的精神分裂即精神病的一種!!

例如:如果能夠證明被告在案發時,他的精神分裂病情令他缺乏理智的程度,足以令他不知道行為是錯的話,法庭便會裁定被告因精神錯亂而殺人,有關控罪便不成立,被告不會被判終身監禁,而只會判入精神病院!而判入幾耐精神病院,則時乎精神病專家的意見來決定!!!

希望解答到你的問題。
如仍有問題,可到我以下的個人網誌:
http://hk.myblog.yahoo.com/david-lee
參考: 本人在課堂上學到的法律知識
2010-07-20 9:00 pm
會,不過就判你誤殺.
2010-07-13 6:07 am
如題,
精神分裂後殺人會否控告殺人罪?

Depend on Circumstances.

Sometime, the Court or Jury will have a verdict of "Acquitted on Mental Ground" Sometime it will return a guilty verdict then sentence to mental institution.

basically depend on how and what circumstance of the crime committed

If and when the person who committed is not in sane mind and from his point of view, the person does not know or cannot distinguish between the right or wrong, the verdict would most likely to be acquitted on mental ground.

However, to achieve that, the defence must demostrate that in the time of the crime (Not before or after) that the defendent are neither able to control his action nor does it have a sane governance on the subject matter, thus cannot reduce to the fact that he is aware of what he/she is doing. Most of the case, the defence need to proof that the action is not preempted and calculated, otherwise the defence will fail.

If acquitted by mental ground, the party will return a NOT GUILTY verdict, but generally will be committed to a mental institute, which since this is a court sanctioned action, this is left a record which is the same as guilty.

When the person, cannot proof beyond reasonable doubt that the murder is commited based on absend mined act, the killing will still be a murder, if the act of murder is led by an mental act, the person will still be sentence to mental institute instead of jail, but the offender will have a criminal record on it if it does.
2010-07-11 8:30 pm
首先,你知知咩係精神分裂:(wi-ki)

精神分裂症,是一種 精神科疾病,是一種持續、通常慢性的重大精神疾病,是精神病裡最嚴重的一種。病因未明,多青壯年發病,隱匿起病,主要影響的心智功能包含思考及對現實世界的感知能力,並進而影響行為及情感。臨床上表現為思維、情感、行為等多方面障礙以及精神活動不協調。患者一般意識清楚。精神分裂症之主要徵兆被認為是基本的思考結構及認知發生碎裂。這種解離現象據信會造成思考形式障礙並導致無法分辨內在及外在的經驗。罹患精神分裂症的人可能會自己表示有幻覺,或者,旁人可以發現他們的表現受幻覺影響。患者也可能表達明顯妄想信念。社交或職業功能退化、一些次要的症狀、沒有器質性腦病,可以是確立診斷的條件。



精神分裂係種精神病,so殺左人係會控殺人!但控殺人有好多種...

這時會判誤殺,並要接受長期精神康復治療!
參考: 由新聞中得=,=

收錄日期: 2021-04-19 22:43:33
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20100711000051KK00530

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份