looping the loop 2

2010-06-13 6:07 am
I asked a question several days ago.

圖片參考:http://imgcld.yimg.com/8/n/HA06578099/o/701006120163813873421710.jpg

According to the answer's of 同(知識長) and 暱稱(小學五年級), both said that after a ball passing throught the highest point, the ball do not fall off the track. In the other words, the ball do not fall off the track provided that the speed is not zero. But I think the ball may fall off only if the speed at the highest point is higher than √(rg).
Here is my extrapolation,




圖片參考:http://imgcld.yimg.com/8/n/HA06578099/o/701006120163813873421721.jpg


R is the normal reaction exerted on the ball by the track
I think only v>√(rg) at the highest point can the ball do not leave the track. Am I correct?

回答 (3)

2010-06-15 12:42 am
✔ 最佳答案
You are right but something should be clarified. If v<√(rg) before it reaches the top, the ball cannot maintain a circular motion even before it reaches the top of the track. Hence, the balls will undergo projectile motion before it reach the top of the track. In your figure, it is clear that you think the ball will undergo projectile motion after it reaches the top. I hope this is what your misconception.
參考: Lucas Chau
2010-06-13 8:03 pm
Since I have given my answer to this question, I have the duty to clarify the doubt.

There is a condition stated in the original question. The ball could reach the highest point of the track. Following the mathematics given here in this new question, it can be seen that the speed of the ball at the highest point v is at least equal to square-root[rg]. If the ball has speed lower than that value, the ball would not reach the highest point, and which violates the condition given in the original question, a situation that should not be considered.

As such, we only need to consider situations where the ball has speed higher than square-root[rg]. For these situations, the speed of the ball should be higher than square-root[rg] when it rolls downward. Then the equation:

mv^2/r = mg.cos(theta) + R
holds, where "theta" is the angle the radius joining the centre of the track to the ball makes with the vertical.
The equation could be easily complied with for increasing value of R from zero.
2010-06-13 7:23 am
Yes, you are right. They may have erroneously assumed that this cause is similar to a roller coaster. For a roller coaster, the car is always stuck to track. Therefore, the car can complete the loop if it has a v > 0 at the highest point.


收錄日期: 2021-04-25 23:16:55
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20100612000051KK01638

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份